The effect of ultrasound on bone healing across a bone gap, an experimental study of a delayed union model

Abstract

The aim of the study is to determine whether ultrasound accelerates bone repair across a bone gap. To replicate the clinical situation of bone repair in a severe tibial fracture, such as Gustilo grade three, we designed an experimental model to determine whether ultrasound can promote bone healing in the presence of a bone gap. The effect of ultrasound on bone healing of a tibial bone gap held in an external fixator was studied. 60 New Zealand White rabbits were divided into four groups. In one group of 6 animals, a tibial osteotomy was closed or compressed and studied at six weeks (Comparative Group). In 3 groups of 18 animals each, a tibial bone gap was maintained and was untreated, treated with ultrasound or mock ultrasound (Control Group). The repair of the bone gaps was studied in 3 animals each at 2,4,6,8,10 and 12 weeks. Investigation was by histology, angiography, radiography and densitometry. Three of the 18 untreated group progressed to delayed union, compared with 4 in the ultrasound and 3 in the mock ultrasound group (Control Group). Statistical analysis showed no difference between the three groups. 5 of the 6 closed/compressed osteotomies (Comparative Group) united faster at 6 weeks. The healing pattern of the bone gap groups were similar. We recommend this as a delayed union model. We found no evidence that ultrasound accelerated bone healing, reduced the rate of delayed union or increased callus formation in this model of delayed union. This study simulates delayed union following a compound tibial fracture and has clinical relevance concerning treatment of a delay in union with ultrasound.