The effect of mutation on an aggregation-prone protein: An in vivo, in vitro, and in silico analysis

Acquisition of mutations is central to evolution; however, the detrimental effects of most mutations on protein folding and stability limit protein evolvability. Molecular chaperones, which suppress aggregation and facilitate polypeptide folding, may alleviate the effects of destabilizing mutations thus promoting sequence diversification. To illuminate how chaperones can influence protein evolution, we examined the effect of reduced activity of the chaperone Hsp90 on poliovirus evolution. We find that Hsp90 offsets evolutionary trade-offs between protein stability and aggregation. Lower chaperone levels favor variants of reduced hydrophobicity and protein aggregation propensity but at a cost to protein stability. Notably, reducing Hsp90 activity also promotes clusters of codon-deoptimized synonymous mutations at inter-domain boundaries, likely to facilitate cotranslational domain folding. Our results reveal how a chaperone can shape the sequence landscape at both the protein and RNA levels to harmonize competing constraints posed by protein stability, aggregation propensity, and translation rate on successful protein biogenesis.

Protein aggregation constitutes a recurring complication in the manufacture and clinical use of therapeutic monoclonal antibodies (mAb) and mAb derivatives. Antibody aggregates can reduce production yield, cause immunogenic reactions, decrease the shelf-life of the pharmaceutical product and impair the capacity of the antibody monomer to bind to its cognate antigen. A common strategy to tackle protein aggregation involves the identification of surface-exposed aggregation-prone regions (APR) for replacement through protein engineering. It was shown that the insertion of N-glycosylation sequons on amino acids proximal to an aggregation-prone region can increase the physical stability of the protein by shielding the APR, thus preventing self-association of antibody monomers. We recently implemented this approach in the Fab region of full-size adalimumab and demonstrated that the thermodynamic stability of the Fab domain increases upon N-glycosite addition. Previous experimental data reported for this technique have lacked appropriate confirmation of glycan occupancy and structural characterization of the ensuing glycan profile. Herein, we mutated previously identified candidate positions on the Fab domain of Trastuzumab and employed tandem mass spectrometry to confirm attachment and obtain a detailed N-glycosylation profile of the mutants. The Trastuzumab glycomutants displayed a glycan profile with significantly higher structural heterogeneity compared to the HEK Trastuzumab antibody, which contains a single N-glycosylation site per heavy chain located in the CH2 domain of the Fc region. These findings suggest that Fab N-glycosites have higher accessibility to enzymes responsible for glycan maturation. Further, we have studied effects on additional glycosylation on protein stability via accelerated studies by following protein folding and aggregation propensities and observed that additional glycosylation indeed enhances physical stability and prevent protein aggregation. Our findings shed light into mAb glycobiology and potential implications in the application of this technique for the development of “biobetter” antibodies.

The various roles that aggregation prone regions (APRs) are capable of playing in proteins are investigated here via comprehensive analyses of multiple non-redundant datasets containing randomly generated amino acid sequences, monomeric proteins, intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) and catalytic residues. Results from this study indicate that the aggregation propensities of monomeric protein sequences have been minimized compared to random sequences with uniform and natural amino acid compositions, as observed by a lower average aggregation propensity and fewer APRs that are shorter in length and more often punctuated by gate-keeper residues. However, evidence for evolutionary selective pressure to disrupt these sequence regions among homologous proteins is inconsistent. APRs are less conserved than average sequence identity among closely related homologues (≥80% sequence identity with a parent) but APRs are more conserved than average sequence identity among homologues that have at least 50% sequence identity with a parent. Structural analyses of APRs indicate that APRs are three times more likely to contain ordered versus disordered residues and that APRs frequently contribute more towards stabilizing proteins than equal length segments from the same protein. Catalytic residues and APRs were also found to be in structural contact significantly more often than expected by random chance. Our findings suggest that proteins have evolved by optimizing their risk of aggregation for cellular environments by both minimizing aggregation prone regions and by conserving those that are important for folding and function. In many cases, these sequence optimizations are insufficient to develop recombinant proteins into commercial products. Rational design strategies aimed at improving protein solubility for biotechnological purposes should carefully evaluate the contributions made by candidate APRs, targeted for disruption, towards protein structure and activity.

Proteins are vital for the regulation of several cellular functions, including the synthesis of structural components. The change in environmental conditions will impact conformational stability and result in aggregation. Protein aggregation involves different states of proteins, like nonnative, unfolded, and native states, which make them complex processes. The proper understanding of protein aggregation pathways involving the role of thermodynamically unfavoured lag phase, soluble protofibrils triggered polymerization through an exponential phase, and depleted free monomers owing to the saturation phase resulted in the leveling off of the polymerization process. The aggregated therapeutic proteins can induce deleterious immune responses in patients, and control of the aggregation is essential for better therapeutic protein stability and targeting with the help of stable protein structures and function. Protein–protein interactions (PPIs) are important for protein stability, aggregation rate, and solubility, while advanced computational and biophysical methods have been developed to characterize therapeutic protein aggregation better. Hence, an effective strategy for controlling, monitoring, and reproducing protein aggregation propensities of the polypeptide chains is required. An in-depth understanding of protein aggregation mechanisms, characterization, and combat strategies will counter the issues of protein aggregation. It will also reduce the cost of the product, time constraints, stable & effective product availability, and potential immunogenicity.Graphical

Mutations in the human TGFBI gene encoding TGFBIp have been linked to protein deposits in the cornea leading to visual impairment. The protein consists of an N-terminal Cys-rich EMI domain and four consecutive fasciclin 1 (FAS1) domains. We have compared the stabilities of wild-type (WT) human TGFBIp and six mutants known to produce phenotypically distinct deposits in the cornea. Amino acid substitutions in the first FAS1 (FAS1-1) domain (R124H, R124L, and R124C) did not alter the stability. However, substitutions within the fourth FAS1 (FAS1-4) domain (A546T, R555Q, and R555W) affected the overall stability of intact TGFBIp revealing the following stability ranking R555W>WT>R555Q>A546T. Significantly, the stability ranking of the isolated FAS1-4 domains mirrored the behavior of the intact protein. In addition, it was linked to the aggregation propensity as the least stable mutant (A546T) forms amyloid fibrils while the more stable variants generate non-amyloid amorphous deposits in vivo. Significantly, the data suggested that both an increase and a decrease in the stability of FAS1-4 may unleash a disease mechanism. In contrast, amino acid substitutions in FAS1-1 did not affect the stability of the intact TGFBIp suggesting that molecular the mechanism of disease differs depending on the FAS1 domain carrying the mutation.

Aggregation-prone Regions in HYPK Help It to Form Sequestration Complex for Toxic Protein Aggregates

An in-silico method for identifying aggregation rate enhancer and mitigator mutations in proteins

Identification of MOAG-4/SERF as a Regulator of Age-Related Proteotoxicity

The proteome of Plasmodium falciparum exhibits a marked propensity for aggregation. This characteristic results from the parasite's AT-rich genome, which encodes numerous proteins with long asparagine-rich stretches and low structural complexity, which lead to abundant intrinsically disordered regions. While this poses challenges for the parasite, the propensity for protein aggregation may also serve functional roles, such as stress adaptation, and could therefore be exploited by targeting it as a potential vulnerable spot in the pathogen. Here, we overexpressed an aggregation-prone segment of the P. falciparum ubiquitin transferase (PfUTf), an E3 ubiquitin ligase protein that has been previously demonstrated to regulate the stability of parasite proteins involved in invasion, development and drug metabolism. Overexpression of PfUTf in P. falciparum had evident phenotypic effects observed by transmission electron microscopy and confocal fluorescence microscopy, increased endogenous protein aggregation, disrupted proteostasis, and caused significant growth impairment in the parasite. Combined with dihydroartemisinin treatment, PfUTf overexpression had a synergistic effect that further compromised the parasite´s viability, linking protein aggregation to proteasome dysfunction. Changes in the distribution of aggregation-prone proteins, shown by the altered subcellular fluorescent pattern of the new investigational aggregated protein dye and antiplasmodial compound YAT2150 in the overexpressing P. falciparum line, highlighted the critical balance between protein aggregation, stress responses, and parasite viability, suggesting proteostasis-targeting therapies as a good antimalarial strategy.

Though protein stability and aggregation have been well characterized in dilute solutions, the influence of a confining environment that exists (e.g., in intercellular and tissue spaces and therapeutic formulations) on the protein structure is largely unknown. Herein, the effects of confinement on stability and aggregation were explored for proteins of different sizes, stability, and hydrophobicity when encapsulated in hydrophilic poly(ethylene glycol) hydrogels. Denaturation curves show linear correlations between confinement size (mesh size) and thermodynamic stability, i.e., unfolding free energy and surface area accessible for solvation (represented by m-value). Two clusters of protein types are identifiable from these correlations; the clusters are defined by differences in protein stability, surface area, and aggregation propensity. Proteins with higher stability, larger surface area, and lower aggregation propensity (e.g., lysozyme and myoglobin) are less affected by the confinement imposed by mesh size than proteins with lower stability, smaller surface area, and higher aggregation propensity (e.g., growth hormone and aldehyde dehydrogenase). According to aggregation kinetics measured by thioflavin T fluorescence, confinement in smaller mesh sizes resulted in slower aggregation rates than that in larger mesh sizes. Compared to that in buffer solution, the confinement of a hydrophobic protein (e.g., human insulin) in the hydrogels accelerates protein aggregation. Conversely, the confinement of a hydrophilic protein (e.g., human amylin) in the hydrogels decelerates or prevents aggregation, with the rates of aggregation inversely proportional to mesh size. These findings provide new insights into protein conformational stability in confined microenvironments relevant to various cellular, tissue, and therapeutics scenarios.

Protein conformational perturbations in hereditary amyloidosis: Differential impact of single point mutations in ApoAI amyloidogenic variants

In contrast to the myriad approaches available to study protein misfolding and aggregation in vitro, relatively few tools are available for the study of these processes in the cellular context. This is in part due to the complexity of the cellular environment which, for instance, interferes with many spectroscopic approaches. Here, we describe a tripartite fusion approach that can be used to assess in vivo protein stability and solubility in the cytosol of Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Our biosensors contain tripartite fusions in which a protein of interest is inserted into antibiotic resistance markers. These fusions act to directly link the aggregation susceptibility and stability of the inserted protein to antibiotic resistance. We demonstrate a linear relationship between the thermodynamic stabilities of variants of the model folding protein immunity protein 7 (Im7) fused into the resistance markers and their antibiotic resistance readouts. We also use this system to investigate the in vivo properties of the yeast prion proteins Sup35 and Rnq1 and proteins whose aggregation is associated with some of the most prevalent neurodegenerative misfolding disorders, including peptide amyloid beta 1-42 (Aβ42), which is involved in Alzheimer's disease, and protein α-synuclein, which is linked to Parkinson's disease.

Investigating protein aggregation in protein-carbohydrate interfaces using sequence and structural features.

The clinical use of protein and peptide biotherapeutics requires fabrication of stable products. This particularly concerns stability towards aggregation of proteins or peptides. Here, we tested a hypothesis that interactions between a synthetic peptide, which is an aggregation-prone region analogue, and its homologous sequence on a protein of interest, could be exploited to design excipients which stabilise the protein against aggregation. A peptide containing the analogue of lysozyme aggregation-prone region (GILQINSRW) was conjugated to a RAFT agent and used to initiate the polymerisation of N-hydroxyethyl acrylamide, generating a GILQINSRW-HEA90 polymer, which profoundly reduced lysozyme aggregation. Substitution of tryptophan in GILQINSRW with glycine, to form GILQINSRG, revealed that tryptophan is a critical amino acid in the protein stabilisation by GILQINSRW-HEA90. Accordingly, polymeric peptide-mimetics of tryptophan, phenylalanine and isoleucine, which are often present in aggregation-prone regions, were synthesized. These were based on synthetic oligomers of acrylamide derivatives of indole-3 acetic acid (IND), phenylacetic acid (PHEN), or 2-methyl butyric acid (MBA), respectively, conjugated with hydrophilic poly(N-hydroxyethyl acrylamide) blocks to form amphiphilic copolymers denoted as INDm-, PHENm- and MTBm-b-HEAn. These materials were tested as protein stabilisers and it was shown that solution properties and the abilities of these materials to stabilise insulin and the peptide IDR 1018 towards aggregation are dependent on the chemical nature of their side groups. These data suggest a structure-activity relationship, whereby the indole-based INDm-b-HEAn peptide-mimetic displays properties of a potential stabilising excipient for protein formulations.

Colloidal stability is among the key challenges the pharmaceutical industry faces during the production and manufacturing of protein therapeutics. Self-association and aggregation processes can not only impair therapeutic efficacy but also induce immunogenic responses in patients. Aggregation-prone regions (APRs) consisting of hydrophobic patches are commonly identified as the source for colloidal instability, and rational strategies to mitigate aggregation propensity often require genetic engineering to eliminate hydrophobic amino acid residues. Here, we investigate cucurbit[7]uril (CB[7]), a water-soluble macrocycle able to form host-guest complexes with aromatic amino acid residues, as a potential excipient to mitigate protein aggregation propensity. Two monoclonal antibodies (mAbs), one harboring an APR and one lacking an APR, were first assessed for their colloidal stability (measured as the translational diffusion coefficient) in the presence and absence of CB[7] using dynamic light scattering. Due to the presence of a tryptophan residue within the APR, we were able to monitor changes in intrinsic fluorescence in response to increasing concentrations of CB[7]. Isothermal titration calorimetry and NMR spectroscopy were then used to characterize the putative host-guest interaction. Our results suggest a stabilizing effect of CB[7] on the aggregation-prone mAb, due to the specific interaction of CB[7] with aromatic amino acid residues located within the APR. This provides a starting point for exploring CB[7] as a candidate excipient for the formulation of aggregation-prone mAbs.