The effect of macular visual field test density on central structure-function concordance in glaucoma

Abstract

ABSTRACT Clinical relevance Central visual field (VF) testing often requires focussed high-density test grids. The critical number of test locations for maximising structure-function concordance in the macula is not known. Purpose The aim of this work is to determine the impact of the number of test locations in the central VF on binarized structure-function concordance in glaucoma. Methods Humphrey Field Analyser (HFA) 10–2 test grid and Cirrus optical coherence tomography Ganglion Cell Analysis (GCA) results from one eye of 155 glaucoma patients were extracted. Following anatomical correction for retinal ganglion cell displacement, the pointwise results of the central 36 locations of the 10–2 pattern deviation map and their corresponding locations within the GCA deviation map were recorded. The number of test locations was systematically reduced from 36 (4 locations per step) and added from 1 (1 location per step) and binarized structure-function concordance (p < 0.05 for both) at each step was evaluated. Eleven test point subtraction and addition models were developed. Concordance rates (proportion) were plotted as a function of number of test locations, and were fitted using segmental nonlinear regression to identify the critical point of inflection at which concordance was maximised and discordance minimised. Results Subtractive and additive approaches returned two-way estimates of the critical number, with, on average 8–14 test locations being the range at which structure-function concordance was optimised in the present cohort across all models. A randomised approach to subtracting or adding test locations returned critical numbers that were similar to systematic and empirical models, suggesting that specific test location was not as critical in optimising structure-function concordance compared to the number of test locations. Conclusion There is a potential critical number (8–14) in macular visual field testing where binarized structure-function concordance is optimised, providing a framework for guiding the development of integrated macular test locations in VF testing for glaucoma.