The effect of local excision and adjuvant radiotherapy for patients with stage I rectal cancer

Abstract

Objective To evaluate the long-term survival and treatment failure patterns for patients with stage Ⅰ adenocarcinoma in the lower rectum after local excision with or without adjuvant radiotherapy.Methods From Jan.2000 to Dec.2008,Seventy-seven patients with rectal cancer received local excision.Among them,41 received adjuvant radiotherapy.Fifty-four patients were pathologically proven as T1,the other 23 as T2.Patients were classified into low-and high-risk groups according to tumor grade,the length of tumor,surgical margin,circumference ratio of tumor/rectum and T stage.Survival rates and prognostic factors were estimated by Kaplan-Meier method,and comparisons were made by the Logrank test.Results Fourty patients were followed up more than 5 years.The 5-year locoregional recurrence-free survival (LRFS)and overall survival (OS) rates were 83％ and 82％ for the whole group.There were no significant differences in 5-year LRFS and OS rates in low-risk patients between local excision alone and local excision followed by adjuvant radiotherapy ( 86％ ∶ 83％,x2 =0.29,P =0.588 and 100％ ∶ 100％,x2 =1.50,P =0.221 ).In high-risk patients,the 5-year LRFS were similar (80％ ∶ 82％,x2 =0.27,P =0.600),but the OS were significantly different (92％∶ 66％,x2 =4.64,P =0.031 ) between local excision alone and local excision followed by adjuvant radiotherapy.By univariate analysis,large tumor size,positive margin,poor differentiation,tumor located less than 5 cm from anal verge and pT2 stage were poor prognostic factors for OS.The overall relapse rate for the whole group was 29％,and 70％ of them were locoregional relapse.The 5-year OS for patients treated with radical salvage surgery after local relapse was 69％.Conclusions For stage Ⅰ lower-sited rectal cancer,low-risk patients can achieve good result after local excision alone.The role of adjuvant radiotherapy in high-risk patients needs further evaluation.Local relapse is the main cause of failure,and salvage surgery after local relapse can provide long-term survival. Key words: Rectal neoplasms/surgery; Rectal neoplasms/radiotherapy; Prognosis