The effect of leader damage on white spruce (Picea glauca) site tree height growth and site index

Abstract

Site trees used to estimate site index are selected based on characteristics that ensure that the tree reflects the potential productivity of the site. Hidden leader damage can make it difficult to identify site trees. Using these trees as site trees could lead to erroneous estimates of site index and height growth trajectories. One hundred and fifteen white spruce (Picea glauca (Moench) Voss) trees were selected, harvested, and split open to identify hidden damage and to quantify the effect of the damage on height growth and site index. A mixed-effects height growth model based on the Chapman–Richards function was formulated. A height growth modifier was included in the model to estimate the effect of leader damage on height growth. It was found that height growth was reduced by 28% in the year that the damage occurred and by 6% and 3% in the following two years. This results in a reduction of about 0.16 m in site index per incidence of damage on average, although this will depend on the age when the damage occurred and the timing between damage events. Since the damage is not outwardly visible, this creates problems when developing and applying site index models.