The effect of implanting various substances into artificially created circumscribed defects in rat femurs

Abstract

1. The effect of implanting heterogenous anorganic bone, homogenous organic bone, autogenous compact bone from the iliac crest, and autogenous bony callus into circumscribed defects in the femur of albino rats of the Wistar strain is described. 2. Neither heterogenous anorganic bone nor homogenous organic bone appeared to induce new bone formation in a healing defect. 3. Some of the osteogenic cells of autogenous callus implants survived transplantation to a bone defect and gave rise to new bone formation. This did not occur when compact bone from autogenous iliac crest was implanted. 4. Implants of autogenous callus, autogenous compact bone, homogenous organic bone and heterogenous anorganic bone all impeded the normal development of host bone trabeculae in a healing bone defect, seemingly because they acted as physical barriers to the proliferating host callus. None of the implant materials appeared to suppress the healing reaction ofthe host. 5. Implanted homogenous organic bone was removed and replaced by host bone more quickly than was implanted heterogenous anorganic bone, and it appears to be the better material for grafting into bone defects. 6. Autogenous callus or autogenous cancellous bone is a superior implant material to autogenous compact bone and is the bone graft material of choice. 7. The absorption of all the implant materials used in this investigation was associated with the presence of multinucleated giant cells. 8. The activity of multinucleated giant cells may be influenced by the organic matrix of the material which is to be absorbed. 9. Except when fresh autogenous callus was implanted into the defects, the rate of healing in the grafted defects was slower than that in the control defects. In the defects grafted with fresh autogenous callus the healing rates of the control and grafted defects were the same.