Abstract

Climate change is already altering the landscape at high latitudes. Permafrost is thawing, the growing season is starting earlier, and, as a result, certain regions in the Arctic may be subjected to an increased incidence of freeze-thaw events. The potential release of carbon and nutrients from soil microbial cells that have been lysed by freeze-thaw transitions could have significant impacts on the overall carbon balance of arctic ecosystems, and therefore on atmospheric CO2 concentrations. However, the impact of repeated freezing and thawing with the consequent growth and recrystallization of ice on microbial communities is still not well understood. Soil samples from three distinct sites, representing Canadian geographical low arctic, mid-arctic and high arctic soils were collected from Daring Lake, Alexandra Fjord and Cambridge Bay sampling sites, respectively. Laboratory-based experiments subjected the soils to multiple freeze-thaw cycles for 14 days based on field observations (0 °C to −10 °C for 12 h and −10 °C to 0 °C for 12 h) and the impact on the communities was assessed by phospholipid fatty acid (PLFA) methyl ester analysis and 16S ribosomal RNA gene sequencing. Both data sets indicated differences in composition and relative abundance between the three sites, as expected. However, there was also a strong variation within the two high latitude sites in the effects of the freeze-thaw treatment on individual PLFA and 16S-based phylotypes. These site-based heterogeneities suggest that the impact of climate change on soil microbial communities may not be predictable a priori; minor differential susceptibilities to freeze-thaw stress could lead to a “butterfly effect” as described by chaos theory, resulting in subsequent substantive differences in microbial assemblages. This perspectives article suggests that this is an unwelcome finding since it will make future predictions for the impact of on-going climate change on soil microbial communities in arctic regions all but impossible.

Highlights

  • If the enhanced resilience of soil microbial communities to freeze-thaw cycle (FTC) can be attributed to adaptation to a particular local climate associated with a geographic region [21], this prompts us to consider that arctic soils from climatically distinct locations could show substantial variation in their responses to FTCs related to climate change

  • Respiration monitoring was consistent with FTCs, showing alternating periods of no detectible CO2 discharge followed by a modest burst of CO2 as the soil thawed

  • Unlike the dramatic changes in DGGE community profiles that are evident after more stressful treatments, our results initially suggested, similar to others [6], that FTCs did not appear to radically shift bacterial community structure in a predictable, consistent way

Read more

Summary

Introduction

Prior to snow accumulation in autumn, and during the spring melt, dynamically fluctuating air temperatures are common and can result in freeze-thaw cycle (FTC) events in surface soils. Such freeze-thaw fluctuations are of ecological interest because of their possible impacts on soil microbial communities, soil carbon and nutrient transformations, as well as plant productivity [3±8]. CO2 release and changes in microbial community composition following rewetting are usually less pronounced in soils frequently exposed to fluctuations in soil water potential in situ (e.g., [31,33,34]) This suggests that community adaptations for stress resistance are shaped by local climate history. As warmer air temperatures initiate above ground, snow and ice melt, with water percolating down into the frozen soil through these sublimed crevices, soil pores, frost-induced cracks, and dendritic channels [36±38]

Freeze-Thaw
Experimental Section
Soil Phospholipid Fatty Acid and DNA Analyses
Results
Implications of the Microcosm Investigations
Implications for Predictions on the Effect of Climate Change
Full Text
Published version (Free)

Talk to us

Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have

Schedule a call