The effect of character stroke width on legibility: The relationship between duty ratio and contrast threshold

Abstract

Stroke width is an important factor affecting letter legibility. Although there seems to be a critical or optimal value for stroke width, it has been difficult to estimate quantitatively because shape deterioration and the increase of stroke width are covariates. This study attempted to predict the optimal value of stroke width considering it as a duty ratio. The duty ratio is related to the amplitude of the fundamental frequency, with the maximum amplitude of the fundamental frequency occurring at a duty ratio of 0.5. The fundamental frequency decreases when the duty ratio is set either lower or higher than 0.5. Based on previous research indicating that letters also have a critical band (CB), or the frequency band which contributes most to letter recognition, which corresponds to their fundamental frequency, we hypothesized that the amplitude of CB is related to the legibility of letters. We measured the contrast thresholds using square-wave gratings and letters of differing duty ratios. In both the grating and letter stimuli, the amplitude of CB reached its maximum when the duty ratio was around 0.5. Contrast thresholds for stimuli with various duty ratios were accurately predicted by the amplitudes of CB and the contrast thresholds in the individual’s sine-wave grating. Our results suggest that the amplitude of a single critical component contributes significantly to the legibility of letters, even though they contain diverse frequency components.