The Effect of Cerclage Banding Distally to a Clamshell Fracture Pattern in Total Hip Arthroplasty-A Biomechanical Study.

Abstract

As currently there is no existing biomechanical work on the topic of interest, the aim of the current study was to investigate the effect of cerclage banding distally to an intraoperatively occurring proximal periprosthetic femoral clamshell fracture versus a non-fractured femur after total hip arthroplasty. A diaphyseal anchoring stem was implanted in twenty paired human cadaveric femora, assigned to a treatment and a control group. In the treatment group, each specimen was fitted with a cerclage band placed 3 mm distally to a clamshell fracture, created with an extent of 40% of the anchoring length of the stem. The resulting fragment was not treated further. The contralateral specimens were left with the stems without further fracture creation or treatment. All constructs were tested under progressively increasing cyclic axial loading until failure. Relative bone-implant movements were monitored by motion tracking. Number of cycles and the corresponding load at stem loosening, defined as 1 mm displacement of the stem along the shaft axis, were 31,417 ± 8870 and 3641.7 ± 887 N in the control group, and 26,944 ± 11,706 and 3194.4 ± 1170.6 N in the treatment group, respectively, with no significant differences between them, p = 0.106. From a biomechanical perspective, cerclage banding distally to an intraoperative clamshell fracture with an extent of 40% of the anchoring length of the stem demonstrated comparable resistance against hip stem loosening versus a non-fractured femur. It may therefore represent a valid treatment option to restore the full axial stability of a diaphyseal anchoring stem. In addition, it may be considered to keep the medial wall fragment unfixed, thus saving operative time and minimizing associated risks.