The effect of a self-monitoring tool on self-efficacy, health beliefs, and adherence in patients receiving hemodialysis

Abstract

Objective: Assess the effectiveness of a self-monitoring tool on perceptions of self-efficacy, health beliefs, and adherence in patients receiving hemodialysis. Design: A monthly intervention using a pretest, posttest design over a 6-month period. Both the treatment and control groups were randomly selected and received surveys to assess health beliefs, perceptions of self-efficacy for performing specific healthful behaviors, and renal diet knowledge at baseline, before intervention, and 6 months later. The treatment group also received monthly feedback of monthly phosphorus levels and interdialytic weight gains. Setting: A university hospital-based 43-chair ambulatory dialysis center. Subjects: Forty patients with end-stage renal disease (25 men and 15 women, age 26 to 78 years), on chronic hemodialysis for at least 2 months and with a history of noncompliance with phosphorus and/or fluid restrictions for 1 or more months. Main outcome measures: Self-efficacy, health beliefs, knowledge, biochemical, and demographic variables were analyzed. Analysis of variance tests of repeated measures were used to examine relationships between adherence with phosphorus and fluid restrictions to health beliefs and perceptions of self-efficacy after training in self-monitoring. Results: Overall, there were no significant improvements in adherence with phosphorus and fluid restrictions between the two groups, although a comparison within the groups revealed the treatment group had a statistically significant decrease in mean phosphorus levels of 7.14 to 6.22 mg/dL ( P = .005) from baseline to month 3. However, because this value was not maintained, it was not statistically significant. No significant differences existed between the two groups for health beliefs and perceptions of self-efficacy. Knowledge scores in the treatment group, however, improved significantly as compared to the control group ( P = .008) and was a significant increase from baseline ( P = .002). In the control group, all scores fell slightly but this difference was not significant. Conclusions: The benefits of patient self-monitoring and behavioral contracting upon adherence in patients on hemodialysis are inconclusive, as serum phosphorus and interdialytic weight gains did not differ between the two groups. The interventional tools also appeared to have little effect on perceptions of self-efficacy and health beliefs. Trends of improvement, however, did exist for phosphorus within the treatment group and subjects in this group had a statistically significant increase in knowledge scores over time. Additional research using repeated measures design is needed to explore the effects of, increased frequency and duration of an intervention on the attainment of patient clinical outcome measures.