The effect of 5E-SWH learning model on students’ view of nature of science

Abstract

View of Nature of Science (NOS) is one of key factors to support students’ scientific literacy. So, it includes in scientific learning goals internationally. As in the literature, the many potential benefits associated with appropriate view of NOS. For instance, it influences students’ learning achievement in science and lets students see how science connected to their real world. The aim of this study was to develop the 5E-SWH learning model to enhance 12th grade students’ view of NOS. Eighty-eight students participated in this study. They were separated into two groups. Forty-four students had learnt biology by using 5E-SWH learning unit, but another group had learnt by using traditional 5E. View of NOS questionnaire that was adapted from the Views of NOS Questionnaire (VNOS-C) was applied with the both groups as pretest and posttest. The questionnaire consisted of ten open-ended items. The semi-structured interview protocol was also used with thirty students and feedback on the lesson record was provided in order to triangulate students’ view of NOS. The analyzed results were approved by peer review. In addition, the during the implementation, data from voice recorder was transcribed and used discourse analysis to show students’ NOS views. There were three aspects that relate to genetics technology content. These aspects included the subjective, empirical, and social and culture. Students’ responses were categorized into 3 groups including informed, adequate and inadequate view. The results showed that the majority of participants held inadequate views of the subjective and empirical aspect at the beginning of the study. In addition, almost student as well as held adequate view of the social and culture aspect and they had misconception in some target NOS aspects. After that, they had learnt genetics technology content by using 5E-SWH learning model for 15 periods (50 min/ period). Both student groups’ view of NOS was compared with each other. The study showed that the group that using 5E-SWH learning model develop their NOS view more than the control group that learnt through on 5E. The experimental group improved to informed view as following 45.46% subjective, 31.82% empirical and 59.09% social and culture. In addition, more than 50% of students shifted their view of NOS to better group in all target aspects. 25.76% of students shifted their view of NOS from inadequate to adequate view and 27.27% of students shifted their view of NOS from inadequate to informed view. 21.21% of students shifted their view of NOS from adequate to informed view. Furthermore, it showed their view of NOS improvement by conversation in class. The feedback on the lesson record was also support that students’ view of NOS were improved by engaging in 5E-SWH learning unit. However, some students’ comment on the lesson showed that they were still familiar with lecture. Therefore, it was the factor that we should concern in view of NOS development. The implications of this research for teachers were that the learning model could use to be the guideline to teach NOS integrate content in the classroom and they can use this learning model to design lesson plan in science.