The Effect of π Contacts between Metal Ions and Fluorophores on the Fluorescence of PET Sensors: Implications for Sensor Design for Cations and Anions

Abstract

The idea that M···C π contacts between diamagnetic heavy metal ions such as Pb(II), Ag(I), Pd(II), or Hg(II) and the anthracenyl fluorophore of adpa ((N-(9-anthracenylmethyl)-N-(2-pyridinylmethyl)-2-pyridinemethanamine) are responsible for quenching the fluorescence of the complexes of these metal ions with adpa is explored crystallographically. The structures of [Pb(adpa)(NO3)2] (1), [Ag(adpa)NO3] (2), [Pd(adpa)NO3]NO3 (3), [Zn(adpa)(NO3)2] (4), and [Cd(adpa)Br2] (5) are reported. The π contacts with the fluorophore are for 1 are a Pb···C π contact of 3.178 Å; for 2, an Ag···C π contact of 3.016 Å; and for 3, a Pd···C π contact of 2.954 Å on the axial site of the Pd(II) ion. The Zn(II) ion in 4 has no Zn···C π contact, with the anthracenyl fluorophore rotated completely away from the Zn(II) ion. These structures confirm that in the Pb(II), Ag(I), and Pd(II) complexes of adpa, which experience strong quenching of fluorescence, there are strong M···C π contacts, as expected if it is the π contacts that quench fluorescence. In contrast, for the Zn(II) adpa complex, which forms no π contact, there is a strong increase in fluorescence intensity. The structure of 5 shows a long Cd···C π contact at 3.369 Å, in contrast to a previously reported structure with two coordinated nitrates where the Cd···C π contact is 3.097 Å. The long Cd···C π contact in [Cd(adpa)Br2] suggests how coordination of Br(-), as well as other more covalently bound ligands such as Cl(-), SCN(-), and S2O3(2-), cause an increase in fluorescence intensity, reported for the Cd(II)adpa complex in 50% CH3OH/H2O. Coordination of covalently bound ligands to the Cd(II) weakens the Cd···C π contact and so enhances fluorescence, whereas more ionically bound ligands such as SO4(2-), NO3(-), or H2O produce a strong Cd···C π contact and weakened fluorescence. Complexes of the Cd(II)/adpa type may form the basis for a new type of anion/small molecule sensor. The tendency of metal ions to form π contacts with aromatic groups is analyzed in terms of the frequency of occurrence of π contacted structures in the literature, as well as by DFT calculations on the adpa complexes.