The Doll Shop Downstairs (review)

Abstract

Reviewed by: The Doll Shop Downstairs Jeannette Hulick McDonough, Yona Zeldis. The Doll Shop Downstairs; illus. by Heather Maione. Viking, 2009 118p. ISBN 978-0-670-01091-2 $14.99 R Gr. 3–4 Nine-year-old Anna is “just the one sort of stuffed in the middle,” between seemingly perfect older sister, Sophie, and seven-year-old Trudy. Luckily, Anna has the comfort and distraction of the family’s doll-repair shop downstairs, where all three girls get to play with the dolls waiting to be mended by Papa and Mama. World War I threatens the family’s livelihood, as Papa is unable to continue ordering doll parts from his German suppliers, while extended family back in Russia may also be in danger, adding to the Jewish family’s stress. When Anna’s favorite doll is finally claimed by her owner, Anna is devastated until the doll’s generous owner comes to the rescue; meanwhile, Anna herself comes to the rescue of her family with a plan to sell new handmade dolls to F.A.O. Schwartz. This is a cozy family story, similar in its New York setting and nostalgic feel to the All-of-a-Kind Family series, and the doll aspect will undoubtedly appeal to many doll-loving girls. The historical elements provide ballast but never overshadow the focus on Anna, her family, and the dolls. The descriptions of the family’s ability to be creative with what they have are especially appealing (and freshly timely), and the sisters’ relationships with one another are authentic in their ups and downs. Present-tense narration, clear and concise writing, and a relatively short page count make this a quick and lively read. Occasional black-and-white illustrations in line and wash help emphasize the period, and they neatly balance prettiness with friendly informality. An author’s note, glossary, and timeline are included. Copyright © 2009 The Board of Trustees of the University of Illinois