The Development of a Collaborative Self-Evaluation Process for Community-Based Participatory Research Partnerships Using the Community-Based Participatory Research Conceptual Model and Other Adaptable Tools

Abstract

The Development of a Collaborative Self-Evaluation Process for Community-Based Participatory Research Partnerships Using the Community-Based Participatory Research Conceptual Model and Other Adaptable Tools Abigail L. Reese, CNM, PhD, Marcelo M. Hanza, MS, Adeline Abbenyi, BS, Christine Formea, PharmD, Sonja J. Meiers, PhD, Julie A. Nigon, BA, Ahmed Osman, BS, Miriam Goodson, MS, Jane W. Njeru, MB, ChB, Blake Boursaw, MS, Elizabeth Dickson, PhD, RN, Mark L. Wieland, MD, MPH, Irene G. Sia, MD, MSc, and Nina Wallerstein, DrPH What Is the Purpose of this Study/Review? • To pilot an approach to self-evaluation and collective reflection for established community-based participatory research (CBPR) partnerships. • To assess the adaptability of existing self-evaluation and collective reflection tools for partnerships to guide their own self-evaluation process. What Is the Problem? • A growing number of CBPR partnerships have formed with increasing success in achieving outcomes, but the evaluation of processes and outcomes has lagged behind. • There is an increasing need, therefore, for collective reflection tools to assist partnerships to maintain and strengthen their partnering practices to be the most effective at achieving desired outcomes over time. • Partnerships need a process that is relevant to their unique combination of histories, needs, and partners, and can facilitate decisions about which partnering practices would benefit from focused attention. What Are the Findings? • Collective reflection is empowering for members of established partnerships. • Self-evaluation is a critical strategy for CBPR partnerships to improve partnering practices, confirm alignment of principles, and conduct strategic planning toward the goal of health equity. • The CBPR conceptual model and other available tools may be adapted to help CBPR partnerships engage in collective reflection and self-evaluation. Who Should Care Most? • Members of established CBPR partnerships with or without a history of self-evaluation. • Partnerships at any stage of development with an interest in evaluating practices and outcomes. [End Page 223] Recommendations for Action • Consider incorporating collective reflection and self-evaluation into the practices and work plans of your partnership. • Consider adapting your own version the CBPR conceptual model. Resources are available at: https://cpr.unm.edu/research-projects/cbpr-project/facilitation_tools.html. • Review additional tools, guides and examples that may be adapted for your own process: https://engageforequity.org/. [End Page 224] Abigail L. Reese University of New Mexico Center for Participatory Research Marcelo M. Hanza Rochester Healthy Community Partnership Mayo Clinic Adeline Abbenyi Rochester Healthy Community Partnership Christine Formea Rochester Healthy Community Partnership Sonja J. Meiers Rochester Healthy Community Partnership Department of Graduate Nursing, Winona State University Julie A. Nigon Rochester Healthy Community Partnership Ahmed Osman Rochester Healthy Community Partnership Miriam Goodson Rochester Healthy Community Partnership Jane W. Njeru Rochester Healthy Community Partnership Mayo Clinic College of Medicine Blake Boursaw University of New Mexico Center for Participatory Research Elizabeth Dickson University of New Mexico Center for Participatory Research Mark L. Wieland Rochester Healthy Community Partnership Mayo Clinic College of Medicine Irene G. Sia Rochester Healthy Community Partnership Mayo Clinic College of Medicine Nina Wallerstein University of New Mexico Center for Participatory Research Copyright © 2019 Johns Hopkins University Press