The deep-water, high-diversity Edgewood-Cathay brachiopod Fauna and its Hirnantian counterpart

Abstract

The last phase of the end-Ordovician extinction event involved substantial sea-level changes. The Oslo/Asker District in Norway is a rare place where the deeper-water early Hirnantian fauna is succeeded by the equivalent deeper-water Edgewood-Cathay Fauna. Both faunas are highly diverse, with the same small-shelled brachiopods, Onniella, Leangella, and Eoplectodonta, dominating. They also share a large number of long-ranging and eurytopic genera. Taxa from contemporary shallower-water environments are rare. Near a third of the brachiopod genera in the Norwegian deeper-water early Hirnantian Fauna went extinct, including seven genera that survived into the Ordovician/Silurian boundary strata. Deeper-water early Hirnatian and Edgewood-Cathay collections are not well-known worldwide. Global quantitative samples from low latitudes, including the Norwegian samples, were compared against each other using NMDS (Non-metric Multidimensional Scaling) with the Bray-Curtis index. Qualitative samples used NMDS with the Raup-Crick index and Network Analysis. The Raup-Crick index sharply differentiated the early Hirnantian and Edgewood-Cathay faunas, possibly due to sensitivity to extinction and origination data. In contrast, the paleogeographic affinity between collections of the two faunas is pronounced using the Bray-Curtis index. Network Analysis also demonstrates regionality; the Edgewood-Cathay Fauna is especially heterogeneous. This contrasts with the shallower-water Hirnantia Fauna, which is more cosmopolitan. Quiet waters below the storm-wave base possibly hindered the spread of larvae, and anoxic plumes of water may have caused further barriers to the lateral spreading of the Edgewood-Cathay Fauna. As in Norway, long-ranging, eurytopic taxa were shared between the two faunas with few typical shallow-water taxa.