The "Dartboard" Column: Second-Hand Information and Price Pressure

Abstract

This study analyzes the effect of second-hand information on the behavior of security prices and volume using analysts' recommendations published in the monthly Dartboard column of the Wall Street Journal. For the two days following the publication of the recommendations, average positive abnormal returns of 4 percent?nearly twice the level of abnormal returns documented in previous research on analyst recommendations?and average volume double normal volume levels on the two days following publication of the recommendations are documented. The positive abnormal return on announcement is partially reversed within 25 trading days. The authors conclude that the positive abnormal return on announcement of the recommendations is a result of naive buying pressure as well as the information content of the analysts' recommendations.