Abstract

Although the constitutional text has remained nearly untouched – only twice has the Spanish Constitution been amended since its enactment in 1978 – global and European governance have deeply transformed the constitutional order. The impact of the process of European integration upon the Constitution is an open and evolving phenomenon, encompassing the challenge to constitutional supremacy, the incorporation of new sources of law, an imbalance between the legislative and executive powers, the enhanced role of the judiciary, the multilevel protection of fundamental rights and the transformation of regionalism as a model for organising the territorial power. First, this report will analyse the constitutional amendments regarding EU membership and the constitutional limits to European integration. Indeed, the only two constitutional amendments were both prompted by the EU. Secondly, the impact of EU integration upon the protection of constitutional rights will be critically examined, with special emphasis on the economic crisis. The obligations deriving from the EU might undermine the protection of constitutional rights, as the introduction of the European Arrest Warrant, the Data Retention Directive and the austerity measures adopted in the context of the economic crisis have shown. Thirdly and more generally, global governance has had constitutional implications, for instance regarding the strengthening of the executive power vis-a-vis the legislative, pressures on the welfare state, the fight against terrorism, the curtailing of powers of the Autonomous Communities and the response to immigration. In this context, it is necessary to recast the relationship between the Global-European spheres and the national constitutional order to ensure respect for the principles of the rule of law, the separation of powers and the protection of fundamental rights.

Highlights

  • The constitutional text has remained nearly untouched – only twice has the Spanish Constitution been amended since its enactment in 1978 – global and European governance have deeply transformed the constitutional order

  • The obligations deriving from the EU might undermine the protection of constitutional rights, as the introduction of the European Arrest Warrant, the Data Retention Directive and the austerity measures adopted in the context of the economic crisis have shown

  • Á Keywords The Constitution of Spain Constitutional amendments regarding Á Á European integration The Spanish Constitutional Court Constitutional review Á Á statistics Fundamental rights The rule of law as defined in Art. 9 of the Á Constitution The principles of legal certainty and legitimate expectations Á Á European Arrest Warrant Data Retention Directive Privatisation of public Á services European Commission and IMF austerity and restructuring programmes, Á social rights and trade union rights Curtailing of the powers of autonomous regions

Read more

Summary

The Spanish

Constitution of 1978 was drafted in the transitional period to democracy in the aftermath of Franco’s dictatorship. General Francisco Franco died on 20 November 1975, putting an end to a long dictatorship established after the Civil War in 1939.1 The Constitution was the outcome of a consensus among the main political parties represented in Parliament after the 1977 June elections. The drafters were conscious of the need to reach a broad agreement about the basic structural principles of the newly established political order. The need to reach a consensus about highly controversial issues, such as the model of political decentralisation, on occasion led to ambiguous constitutional provisions in need of further interpretation and political negotiations. The Constitution was ratified in a referendum on 6 December 1978

On the whole, the key elements of the rationale of the
The Spanish Constitution has been amended only twice since its enactment in 1978
In terms of the process for constitutional amendment, the Spanish
Conceptualising Sovereignty and the Limits to the Transfer of Powers
The foregoing decision was delivered in the context of the ratification of the
Democratic Control
The Reasons for, and the Role of, EU Amendments
Title I of the Spanish Constitution, entitled ‘Fundamental
In the last decade, the
Constitutional Rights, the European Arrest Warrant and EU Criminal Law
In Spain, the competent authority to issue a
The European Commission
The Right to a Fair Trial and In Absentia Judgments
The Right to a Fair Trial
Other Aspects of EU Criminal Law – The Principle of Ne Bis in Idem
The EU Data Retention Directive
Unpublished or Secret Legislation
In the last two decades
The Treaty Establishing the European Stability Mechanism (ESM Treaty) imposes on
Other initiatives such as Eurobonds and the Banking Union were seen in
Judicial review of EU measures in
The implementation of EU law has entailed challenges in
2.10.1 The CJEU has repeatedly declared that the constitutional traditions common to the
2.11 Article 53 of the Charter and the Issue of Stricter Constitutional Standards
2.12 Democratic Debate on Constitutional Rights and Values
2.13 Experts’ Analysis on the Protection of Constitutional Rights in EU Law
Constitutional Rules on International Organisations and the Ratification of Treaties
The Position of International Law in National Law
The Constitution does not give a decisive role to
In line with the limited oversight of Parliament, referendum is scarcely used in
The CC is in charge of reviewing the constitutionality of international treaties
The Social Welfare Dimension of the Constitution
Findings
Constitutional Rights and Values in Selected Areas of Global Governance
Full Text
Published version (Free)

Talk to us

Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have

Schedule a call