The competitive effects of volunteer barley (Hordeum vulgare) on the growth of oilseed rape (Brassica napus)

Abstract

SummaryThe effects of competition from volunteer barley (Hordeum vulgare) on the growth and yield of oilseed rape (Brassica napus) were investigated in four experiments over three seasons. The growth of rape in the autumn was reduced by 50 ‐ 91 % by competition from 400 barley plants m‐2. A lower barley density of 200 plants m‐2 had less effect but still reduced growth of rape by 65 ‐ 81% in two of the experiments and 25 ‐ 40% in the other two. During winter and spring the barley decreased in vigour and in the spring the rape started to recover, especially on the early drilled (23 ‐ 30 August) plots. The rape sown in mid‐September recovered less quickly. In Experiment 3, herbicides applied in November to control barley did not result in increased growth of rape in winter but led to greater recovery in spring. The barley died during the winter in Experiments 2 and 4, even in the absence of herbicides. Despite the marked effects of barley on the growth of rape in the autumn, yields on plots that had previously contained 200 barley plants m‐2 were reduced by a maximum of only 16% in three of the experiments. In Experiment 3, where the barley was most competitive, this density and 400 plants m‐2 lowered yields by 39% and 78%, respectively. Where a herbicide was used in November to control the barley these yield losses were reduced to 5%. In many rape crops the cost of herbicide treatment would be greater than the financial returns from the expected increase in yield resulting from the control of weeds. Possible reasons for the small loss in yield of rape from barley densities that had substantial effects on the growth of rape in the autumn are discussed.