The cognitive aids in medicine assessment tool (CMAT) applied to five neonatal resuscitation algorithms

Abstract

The International Liaison Committee on Resuscitation (ILCOR) provides recommendations on neonatal resuscitation training and practice, which includes a template for a decision-making algorithm. We evaluated the design properties of the ILCOR algorithm and four adaptations by member resuscitation organizations using the validated Cognitive Aids in Medicine Assessment Tool (CMAT). Two experts rated five neonatal resuscitation algorithms against the CMAT and against medical device design criteria. The ILCOR algorithm scored 32 of a possible 60 CMAT points, showing an adherence rate to CMAT of 53%. The ILCOR algorithm scored higher than the design variations by member organizations. Nonetheless, there are design limitations in the ILCOR algorithm. In principle, cognitive aids can improve neonatal resuscitation team performance; however, a considered design process that incorporates the full complexity of the 'procedure as performed' is needed to improve future versions of the algorithm for incorporation in international guidelines.