The Cambridge Introduction to Emmanuel Levinas by Michael M. Morgan (review)

Abstract

Reviewed by: The Cambridge Introduction to Emmanuel Levinas by Michael M. Morgan Ruth Grossman The Cambridge Introduction to Emmanuel Levinas Michael M. Morgan. New York: Cambridge University Press, 2011. 259 pp. Much has been written in praise of Michael Morgan’s previous book, Discovering Levinas (2007). The book has correctly been hailed as having filled an important gap in Anglo-American readership of Levinas. In his former book, Morgan strives to connect and relate Levinas with Anglo-American philosophy. Morgan’s recent book, The Cambridge Introduction to Emmanuel Levinas (2011), is a further helpful contribution to Levinas scholarship, although it is admittedly an abridged and revised version of the former. Morgan opens the first chapter of both books through a reading of Vasily Grossman’s Life and Fate, a favorite literary reference for Levinas toward the end of his career. This exposition is a helpful portrayal of Levinas’s ethical concerns in a nutshell. Morgan’s opening presentation of Levinas’s ethics through Grossman’s novel is both original and sensitive and offers a glimpse into Levinas’s unique philosophy. Nevertheless, although this chapter worked well in the previous book, the repetition of this episodic appeal [End Page 210] to Grossman’s novel in the first chapter of an introductory book is not an obvious choice. Morgan chooses to plunge into the depths of Levinas’s ethical metaphysics early on, hoping that newcomers will bear with him. The second chapter deals with questions of Levinas’s method and approach to ethics, offering an extensive discussion of the face-to-face relationship. The main issue Morgan explores is whether the face-to-face relation is a transcendental condition for the possibility of meaningful experience or a concrete experience that is empirically produced in everyday life. Morgan presents both arguments comprehensively, balancing between commentators who offer interpretations for the different readings. The chapter discusses Levinas’s face-to-face in its relation to phenomenology and to transcendental philosophy, leading to an understanding that Levinas, similarly to Wittgenstein, does not fit comfortably into conventional descriptive categories. Chapters 3 and 4 deal primarily with ideas central to Totality and Infinity and other essays dating from around its publication. Chapter 3 deals with the ethical content of the face, focusing on the self’s encounter with the other as that which bestows priority to ethics over language and community. Morgan mentions Bernard Williams’s reference to “thick” moral concepts as a helpful term in understanding Levinas’s “face,” as well as Stanley Cavell’s concept of “acknowledgment” as exceeding the scope of knowledge. Morgan then turns to Levinas’s later writing and the new terms associated with the face, such as obsession, substitution, and hostage. Chapter 4 once again takes up the way the face is primordial, whether as transcendental or as occurring within everyday life. The focus here is on Levinas’s treatment of philosophy as totality and the role of infinity in breaching it. Morgan starts by struc turing the discussion around modernist and postmodernist outlooks, relating them to Levinas’s concepts of totality and infinity. The discussion addresses Descartes’s famous third meditation, which Morgan relates to Charles Taylor’s treatment of shame and Franz Rosenzweig’s critique of totality. Chapter 5 deals with subjectivity, presenting Levinas’s early and later versions as essentially continuous. Morgan does not see a rift between the versions but rather a development. He presents the later version as Levinas’s effort to rethink rather than replace anthropocentrism. In Morgan’s view, Levinas at first presents the self as existing prior to the face-to-face and later argues that the self is always already in a social setting. How the difference between these views is to be reconciled is not addressed. [End Page 211] Chapter 6 concerns the relationship between God and ethics. Morgan investigates Levinas’s appropriation of religious and theological language. Once again, Morgan is of the view that Otherwise than Being elaborates and develops what appeared earlier in Totality and Infinity, rather than changes his position. Chapter 7 looks at time and history. Morgan surveys Levinas’s early treatment of time in Time and the Other. He tries to make sense of Levinas...