The application of statistical and novel unsupervised machine learning methodology to forensic hair analysis

Abstract

ABSTRACT Hair colour is a valuable feature in forensic hair analysis and hair comparisons. Five hundred microscopic images of hair shafts were taken and for each image and colour model (RGB, CIE XYZ and CIE L*a*b*) values for each image were determined. The discriminating power of the three colour model values using statistical and unsupervised machine learning methods was evaluated. Additionally, the discriminating power of the images of the same hair shafts using unsupervised machine learning methods was evaluated. All methods were compared to determine which method had the greatest discriminating power to best distinguished between participants and accurately assigned hair to an individual and assist in forensic hair comparisons. The RGB colour model demonstrated the highest discriminating power of the colour model values while the CIE L*a*b* model achieved complete discrimination with a reduced number of participants. The unsupervised k-means model yielded similar results. Unsupervised PCA/k-means and agglomerative clustering models demonstrated low discrimination power of the images, suggesting the existence of additional features within the data beyond colour. This research highlights the significance of the incorporation of colour values in forensic hair comparisons and for further exploration of the incorporation of other hair features, beyond colour values.