Abstract

The article substantiates the necessity of a system analysis of the processes of applicationof the norms of international treaties by commercial courts of the Russian Federation. Thisneed is justified, at least, by the following: an insignificant amount of special research inthis field in comparison with a similar subject within the courts of general jurisdiction, thecreation of a relatively new body of supranational control over compliance with the normsof international treaties in the field of commercial courts’ practice.The purpose of the study is to identify problems of application of international treaties ofthe Russian Federation arbitration courts of Russia.The author uses methodology of formal legal analysis of Russian legislation and courts’ decisions.The results and scope of it’s application. The author, taking into account the specifics ofcommercial proceedings and the nature of disputes heard in commercial courts, proposedlegal grounds in a concentrated form which allow to state the existence of the obligation toapply the norms of international treaties by Russian commercial courts. Two levels of suchgrounds can be stated – international and domestic.Publication of the texts of international treaties as a problematic segment of their applicability.The article highlights one of the problematic segments of the application process ofthe norms of international treaties for the purpose of more detailed reflection. The practiceof commercial courts demonstrates that in both legislative acts and acts of applying law,the concepts of "official publication" and "bringing to the public" are alternated with eachother. Despite the reform, the procedure of official publication has not acquired the characterof a systemic institution of Russian law. This significantly complicates the activity ofadministering justice with respect to the legislative acts of international law.Conclusions. From the point of view of international law, the state, independently determiningthe procedure and methods of implementing international treaties within its legalsystem, is not limited in its ability to burden itself with the need to abide by additional proceduresnot provided by the international legal system of procedures. Official publication,as a necessary procedure for the entry of a legislative act into the force, represents such anadditional procedure designed to protect more effectively human rights and freedoms andto streamline law enforcement practice. In this connection, the author formulated the provisions,the implementation of which can help in matters of systematization of the institutionof official publication of international treaties of the Russian Federation.

Highlights

  • В статье обосновывается необходимость системного анализа процессов применения норм международных договоров арбитражными судами Российской Федерации

  • The article substantiates the necessity of a system analysis of the processes of application of the norms of international treaties by commercial courts of the Russian Federation

  • The author, taking into account the specifics of commercial proceedings and the nature of disputes heard in commercial courts, proposed legal grounds in a concentrated form which allow to state the existence of the obligation to apply the norms of international treaties by Russian commercial courts

Read more

Summary

Conclusions

From the point of view of international law, the state, independently determining the procedure and methods of implementing international treaties within its legal system, is not limited in its ability to burden itself with the need to abide by additional procedures not provided by the international legal system of procedures. No 8 «О действии международных договоров Российской Федерации применительно к вопросам арбитражного процесса», согласно которым международные договоры, заключенные на уровне министерств и ведомств, подлежат официальному опубликованию в официальных изданиях этих органов. В результате подробного описания проблемы с официальным опубликованием международных договоров в Российской Федерации автор указывает лишь, что «вступивший в законную силу международный договор подлежит добросовестному исполнению и применению, а его своевременное опубликование способствует этому». Из информации к ДОПОГ в справочно-правовой системе «КонсультантПлюс» следует, что данный документ вступил в силу 29 января 1968 г., а для Российской Федерации – с 28 апреля 1994 г. Следует также дать официальное разъяснение в части применения арбитражными судами только тех международных договоров РФ, которые официально опубликованы, независимо от того, что такие договоры могут напрямую не затрагивать права и свободы именно человека и гражданина. Что за юридическим лицом (коммерческим предприятием) всегда стоит человек

СПИСОК ЛИТЕРАТУРЫ
BIBLIOGRAPHIC DESCRIPTION
Full Text
Published version (Free)

Talk to us

Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have

Schedule a call