The Allegany Senecas and Kinzua Dam: Forced Relocation through Two Generations

Abstract

In the late 1950s, the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers announced its intention construct a dam along the Allegheny River in Warren, Pennsylvania. The building of the Kinzua Dam was highly controversial because it flooded one-third of the Allegany Reservation of the Seneca Nation of Indians. Nearly six hundred Senecas were forced abandon their homes and relocate, despite a 1794 treaty that had guaranteed them those lands in perpetuity. In this revealing study, Joy A. Bilharz examines the short and long-term consequences of the relocation of the Senecas. Granted unparalleled access members of the Seneca Nation and reservation records, Bilharz traces the psychological, economic, cultural, and social effects over two generations. The loss of homes and tribal lands was heartwrenching and initially threatened undermine the foundations of social life and subsistence economy for the Senecas. Over time, however, many Senecas have managed adapt successfully relocation, creating new social networks, invigorating their educational system, and becoming more politically involved on local, tribal, and national levels. Today the Kinzua Dam is, according Bilharz, a potent symbol for the Senecas. For the younger generation, faced with a reservation land shortage, it represents powerlessness, providing them with ample reasons blame their parents and continue mistrust the federal and state governments. For the older generation, the risen riverbanks have acquired an almost spiritual significance. In the evenings many continue wander down the reservoir banks to be near where the 'old places' used be. Joy A. Bilharz is an assistant professor of anthropology at SUNY College at Fredonia. She is currently serving as lead ethnographer and coprincipal investigator of a pan-Iroquoian survey and study commissioned by the National Park Service.