The Aesthetics and Politics of the Abstract Line in Bhimayana: Experiences of Untouchability

Abstract

When Bhimayana: Experiences of Untouchability, a graphic biography of the life of B. R. Ambedkar, was first published in 2011, it was welcomed as an enunciation of Dalit identity and as a uniquely Indian counterpart to the Western sequential art of comics in its use of Pardhan Gond artistic practices. My argument for moving beyond the twin poles of ‘Dalit identity’ and ‘tribal art’ is threefold. First, a close reading of Bhimayana reveals that the narrative emphasis is not so much on caste as identity as it is a critique of the processes involved in that very identity. Second, the visual style of Bhimayana does not merely mirror the political concerns of the text; the images are an aesthetic response to the ‘problem’ of identity as enunciated in the linear narrative. Third, in order to identify how exactly the images form such a response, we need to arm ourselves with an alternative methodology. The question is therefore how to read, how to look—what is the ideal spectatorial position for the pages of Bhimayana such that it critically intersects with the question of identity? The analysis of the visual object at a ‘subrepresentative’ realm, therefore, becomes the key to breaking out of old habits of looking at the image as a site of representation towards the possibility that the politics of image-making lies instead in its aesthetic intensities.