The Accuracy and Cost-Effectiveness of MRI Assessment of Collateral Ligament Injuries of the Lesser Digits' Proximal Interphalangeal Joints.

Abstract

BackgroundCollateral ligament injuries of the thumb and lesser digits are simple injuries, but they may lead to disabilities in hand function. This study aimed to evaluate the accuracy and cost-effectiveness of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) in diagnosing proximal interphalangeal (PIP) collateral ligament injuries of lesser digits.MethodsA retrospective evaluation was conducted on 18 fingers that had undergone surgery for PIP joint complete collateral ligament injury. Pre-operative MRI results were compared with the intra-operative findings. The data from MRI and direct intraoperative findings were analyzed by the Chi-square test in paired groups. The McNemar test analyzed the accuracy of the MRI test for detecting volar plate injuries. Statistical Packages for Social Sciences (SPSS) version 25 (IBM Inc., Armonk, New York) software program was used for the analysis. ResultsIn digits other than the thumb, the accuracy of MRI for detecting collateral injuries was 38.89%, and detection was incorrect in 11 (61.11%) of 18 patients. There are significant differences between MRI and Intraoperative results (p<0.001). MRI findings for seven fingers (38.89%) of the 18 fingers involved were compatible with the surgery results (38.88%). By comparison, the MRI findings of 11 fingers (61.11%) were inconsistent with the intra-operative results. Eight patients (44.44%) were diagnosed preoperatively with MRI as having volar plate ruptures, three patients (16.67%) were diagnosed with open surgery, but only three of the volar plate diagnosed patients with MRI were verified as ruptures during open surgery (38.0%). In addition, preoperatively undetected volar plate injuries by MRI (n=10) were detected intra-operatively in three cases (30.0%). Therefore, the accuracy of MRI was found not to be statistically significant for the detection of volar plate injuries (p=0.727).ConclusionThis study concluded that a 1.5-Tesla MRI with a slice thickness of 2-3 mm should not be relied on as a decisive tool for diagnosing collateral ligament injuries of the PIP joint of the lesser digits. Additionally, MRI was found insufficient for diagnosing volar plate injuries that accompanied collateral ligament injuries. Given these findings, one might conclude that MRI is not cost-effective in diagnosing collateral ligament injuries of the lesser digits PIP joint.