The absence of lateral fusion in cloacal partition

Abstract

Background/purpose: The mechanism by which the cloaca becomes partitioned into a dorsal rectal part and a ventral genitourinary sinus has been the subject of speculation for more than a century. Despite repeated suggestions that partitioning of the cloaca by fusion of lateral folds does not occur, the concept continues to hold sway in many student and surgical texts. The authors reviewed the histologic and 3-dimensional appearance of the urorectal septum in human and rat embryos to see if there was any evidence of lateral fusion in its formation. Methods: Sprague-Dawley rat embryos (n = 143) were examined between 11 and 21 days’ gestation and compared with human embryo sections (57 embryos) held in historical collections in Europe. Rat embryos were examined by microscopy, dissection, and serial histologic section. In addition, some specimens were sectioned in wax until the lumen of the cloaca was reached, after which they were dewaxed and the internal cavities imaged with scanning electronmicroscopy (n = 18 of 143). Results: Cloacal “partitioning” resulted from a combination of growth of the mesenchyme of the hindgut and genitourinary sinus, an alteration in the position of the cloaca in relation to surrounding structures secondary to growth in the ventral, infraumbilical abdominal wall and changes in the curvature of the developing spine, and apoptosis in the dorsal wall of the cloaca with shortening of the dorsal cloacal wall. There was no septum, as it is usually defined, between the developing bladder and hindgut. There was no evidence on either histologic section or scanning electronmicroscopy of any process of fusion occurring between the 2 lateral folds within the lumen of the cloaca. Conclusions: Lateral fusion of the side walls of the cloaca does not play a role in cloacal “partition.” Development of the bladder and hindgut occurs by a process that involves growth, differentiation, and remodeling.