Testing Cultivar-specific Tipburn Sensitivity of Lettuce for Indoor Vertical Farms

Abstract

Low evaporative conditions in indoor (vertical) farms reduce mass-flow–driven transport of calcium (Ca), resulting in tipburn of lettuce. Lettuce tipburn symptoms develop along the margins of young leaves and the growing shoot tip, where necrotic tissue forms as a result of Ca deficiency. For indoor farms, lettuce tipburn poses a major economic risk because the crop becomes unmarketable as a result of its appearance. Difference in tipburn sensitivity among cultivars has been thought to be related to differences in growth rate, morphology, or anthocyanin production, whereas most commercial lettuce cultivars have been known to express tipburn symptoms in the indoor farm setting. We created a tipburn-inducing growing condition in walk-in growth chambers that limits plant potential transpiration rate while achieving relatively high growth rates, and examined 10 commercial cultivars selected for tipburn sensitivity. Selected cultivars differ in morphology (butterhead, romaine, and leafy type) and color (red or green; resulting from anthocyanin production). All cultivars expressed visually detectable tipburn symptoms 22 ± 2.6 days after transplanting, and varied tipburn rates of 7% to 41% of all leaves at the time of harvest (28 days after transplanting). Despite cultivar-specific variation, neither lettuce morphology nor anthocyanin content were significantly correlated with the incidence or severity of tipburn. However, cultivars recommended for “indoor” production by seed suppliers had less tipburn severity than those recommended for outdoor or both indoor and outdoor production systems. Although tipburn risk may vary under other environmental conditions, low evaporative conditions in this experiment caused tipburn symptoms in all tested cultivars at varying degrees of severity. Cultivar-specific average yield and tipburn severity were not correlated with the Ca concentrations in the inner leaves, suggesting that the amount of tissue Ca required to prevent tipburn is cultivar specific and not related to yield. Our selected tipburn-inducing condition was found to be effective in comparing tipburn sensitivity of lettuce cultivars for indoor farm settings, and similar fast-growing but low-evaporative conditions should be used to assess cultivars for indoor farm production.