Test of lepton universality in beauty-quark decays

R Aaij ,M Gandelman ,M Mccann ,Shuaiyi Liu ,S Ely ,A Lai ,J García Pardiñas ,A Obłąkowska-Mucha ,I Carli ,R Lefèvre ,M Ferrillo ,J Cerasoli ,G Alkhazov ,B Batsukh ,B Małecki ,P K Resmi ,R E Geertsema ,C Meaux ,K Arzymatov ,A Semennikov ,F Betti ,A Usachov ,V Chulikov ,M Van Beuzekom ,M Goncerz ,M Kucharczyk ,J J Malczewski ,M Stahl ,P Vincent ,K Rinnert ,Iaroslava Bezshyiko ,B Quintana ,C Marín Benito ,H.-P Dembinski ,C Parkes ,B Audurier ,C Frei ,Sergio Gómez Fernández ,R Jacobsson ,H V Cliff ,A Cardini ,M Birch ,G Casse ,A Güth ,F Polci ,M Sarpis ,J Lomba Castro ,R Mcnulty ,P Stefko ,M J Bradley ,M Slater ,G Frau ,Maria Aranzazu Oyanguren ,G Wilkinson ,F Stagni ,H Dijkstra ,Eduard Ursov ,S Sellam ,J B Zonneveld ,Shiyang Li ,L Anderlini ,B G Siddi ,C Sanchez Gras ,S Neubert ,S Bhasin ,S Amato ,A Lusiani ,C Patrignani ,M Materok ,G Manca ,J F Marchand ,M Cattaneo ,R A Fini ,Q J Xu ,Y Pan ,T Skwarnicki ,J Haimberger ,I Polyakov ,J Mauricio ,E Shmanin ,D Y Tou ,V S Kirsebom ,Henryk Karol Giemza ,L Giubega ,R Schwemmer ,K Prasanth ,D De Simone ,S Simone ,R Kopecna ,D Strekalina ,M S Soares ,S G Weber ,Yiming Li ,T Kvaratskheliya ,M Chrząszcz ,F Dordei ,L E Yeomans ,G D Lafferty ,S E Hollitt ,M Schiller ,J Ruiz Vidal ,P Vázquez Regueiro ,P Ilten ,S L Yang ,M Féo ,A Mauri ,L Promberger ,A Vagner ,C Gu ,Sook Hyun Lee ,J J Saborido Silva ,D Torres Machado ,B Fang ,M Petruzzo ,M Poliakova ,N Harnew ,E Spadaro Norella ,M Pappagallo ,O De Aguiar Francisco ,S Easo ,L M Garcia Martin ,F Maciuc ,B Meadows ,J Baptista De Souza Leite ,M Vieites Diaz ,К Ившин ,T Shears ,C Betancourt ,H Afsharnia ,Е Говоркова ,E Thomas ,M Wilkinson ,I A Monroy ,F J P Soler ,Wenqian Huang ,S Mariani ,V Bellée ,J M Basels ,C Langenbruch ,P Pais ,Y Amhis ,C Gaspar ,M Artuso ,O Leroy ,A Romero Vidal ,S Farry ,R Forty ,T J V Bowcock ,A Venkateswaran ,X Han ,M Van Veghel ,B Rachwał ,D Gerick ,A Falabella ,M De Cian ,K Petridis ,W Parker ,I Williams ,L Sestini ,D Hill ,D Lancierini ,C Nguyen-Mau ,P Owen ,Xuesong Liu ,S Borghi ,N Nikitin ,M E Stramaglia ,N Meinert ,L Minzoni ,R Lane ,J C Smallwood ,T Nanut ,Maik Becker ,S Filippov ,H Schindler ,H Cai ,G Bassi ,M F Cicala ,D Popov ,Andrea Lampis ,G Passaleva ,A Ustyuzhanin ,R Ma ,S Schael ,S Kotriakhova ,E Cogneras ,M P Blago ,Wenhua Hu ,A B Morris ,A Berezhnoy ,T Gershon ,B R Gruberg Cazon ,B Saitta ,Hilbrand Steffen Kuindersma ,S T’jampens ,Z Aliouche ,P Spradlin ,D Savrina ,A Boyer ,M Karpov ,N Sagidova ,C J G Onderwater ,A Contu ,A Szabelski ,E Ben-Haim ,V Tisserand ,C Santamarina Ríos ,J Hu ,E Dall’occo ,F Redi ,R Bernet ,O Zenaiev ,F Lazzari ,V Dobishuk ,D Vieira ,C R Jones ,S Eisenhardt ,G Graziani ,M Fontana ,M Needham ,E Zaffaroni ,F Kress ,D Marangotto ,Guoming Liu ,L Cojocariu ,L Eklund ,L Calero Diaz ,P Baladrón Rodríguez ,L R Madhan Mohan ,G Ciezarek ,B Mitreska ,H Viemann ,Philippe Charpentier ,R Silva Coutinho ,B Spaan ,X Cid Vidal ,Igor Slazyk ,F Ratnikov ,S Luchuk ,D A Milanés ,S Kholodenko ,И Белов ,R Le Gac ,Yutong Li ,M Ramos Pernas ,R Cardinale ,S Stone ,A Ossowska ,O Kitouni ,A Butkevich ,E Smith ,Zhihao Xu ,C Matteuzzi ,I Kostiuk ,Д Деркач ,A Jawahery ,J D Shupperd ,M Hatch ,T Mombächer ,P A Günther ,D Manuzzi ,L Carus ,J He ,Z Máthé ,N Bondar ,M Palutan ,Hengne Li ,O Kot ,В Жуков ,F Ferrari ,Y Luo ,T Ruf ,E Millard ,P Campana ,D Hutchcroft ,B Khanji ,E Luppi ,Thomas Peter Jones ,S Petrucci ,Alex Daniel Fernez ,C Giugliano ,M Lucio Martínez ,Alexander Mclean Marshall ,J H Lopes ,James Vincent Mead ,M Veltri ,S Cholak ,T Fiutowski ,C J Pawley ,V Coco ,R Waldi ,N Neufeld ,J J Lane ,T Blake ,E Franzoso ,E Jans ,T Grammatico ,Y Zheng ,S Escher ,A B Rodrigues ,F Suljik ,A Fernández Prieto ,J P Grabowski ,Jianchun Wang ,C Burr ,N Sahoo ,G Simi ,F F Wilson ,A Gallas Torreira ,T Evans ,R Quagliani ,F Goncalves Abrantes ,B Dey ,F Blanc ,E Maurice ,G Robertson ,F L Souza De Almeida ,D Hynds ,N Skidmore ,F Fontanelli ,A G Downes ,P Muzzetto ,B Adeva ,A Andreianov ,J L Cobbledick ,A Bay ,T Ketel ,K A Thomson ,J M Durham ,A G Morris ,V Romanovskiy ,A Petrov ,J Fan ,O Deschamps ,L Pica ,S Didenko ,M Piccini ,S Bachmann ,J T Borsuk ,Elisabet Golobardes ,Vladimir Gligorov ,F Pisani ,M Patel ,C Remon Alepuz ,A J Chadwick ,V Belavin ,Artur Ishteev ,P Billoir ,M Schmelling ,Zirui Wang ,J M Otalora Goicochea ,Dongliang Zhang ,K Belous ,T Kirn ,A Massafferri ,V Balagura ,Philippe Ghez ,T Ovsiannikova ,G Valenti ,P Koppenburg ,M Pepe Altarelli ,T Halewood-Leagas ,S Celani ,S Schulte ,M Rama ,Yilong Wang ,G J Pomery ,C Pappenheimer ,A Schopper ,Mario Edgardo Olivares ,K Świentek ,K Heinicke ,Yu Zhang ,Jussara De Miranda ,C Bertella ,M Williams ,I Solovyev ,C Gotti ,M Shapkin ,H Sazak ,A Dendek ,C Bozzi ,W Krzemień ,H Mu ,Huanhuan Liu ,M Adinolfi ,C Vázquez Sierra ,A Palano ,A M Donohoe ,K Heijhoff ,D Gerstel ,A Tully ,C Hasse ,L Del Buono ,A Grecu ,P D’argent ,A Bondar ,J J Back ,S Cadeddu ,V Denysenko ,A Philippov ,S Taneja ,D Maisuzenko ,Y Kang ,R Currie ,A Inglessi ,S Akar ,S Vecchi ,A Davis ,Yanxi Zhang ,F Dettori ,V Jevtic ,S Ferreres Sole ,V Maćko ,J D Roth ,R Calladine ,J Buytaert ,Xu Li ,P Collins ,M Idzik ,M Mulder ,J Ryżka ,A Sarti ,J Closier ,S Maddrell-Mander ,M Franco Sevilla ,R Oldeman ,R Lindner ,O Yushchenko ,M Romero Lamas ,D Pinci ,S Kandybei ,A Brossa Gonzalo ,V Duk ,Ao Xu ,Di Yang ,A Alfonso Albero ,X Liang ,A Chernov ,J A B Coelho ,A Poluektov ,G Chatzikonstantinidis ,M Martinelli ,M S Bieker ,S Monteil ,M Brodski ,M Calvi ,D Galli ,A Chubykin ,M Petrič ,Alberto Dos Reis ,O Steinkamp ,M Bjørn ,A Rollings ,H C Bernstein ,K Müller ,F Archilli ,L Kravchuk ,C Trippl ,Jan Langer ,D A Friday ,B K Jashal ,C J Parkinson ,J Cogan ,T Pajero ,P J Marshall ,L Tomassetti ,P Gandini ,M Mikhasenko ,V Renaudin ,Chen Chen ,N V Raab ,S Esen ,R Vazquez Gomez ,S A Wotton ,A Kharisova ,B Garcia Plana ,E M Niel ,R I Rabadán Trejo ,V Placinta ,X Vilasis‐Cardona ,A Pearce ,H Stevens ,E Graugés ,Aleksandr Solovev ,R Newcombe ,M Hushchyn ,Z Ajaltouni ,Peilian Li ,L Henry ,L Calefice ,O Boente García ,A Pellegrino ,P Carniti ,S Braun ,W Qian ,Shunan Zhang ,J Bhom ,M Morandin ,W Byczynski ,Philipp Roloff ,J S Yu ,Y Zhou ,D Murray ,S Legotin ,M Marinangeli ,T Colombo ,T Ackernley ,S Meloni ,I Gorelov ,B Pagare ,P De Simone ,T Maltsev ,A Sergi ,P Seyfert ,M Garau ,S Zucchelli ,G Panshin ,M Kreps ,C M Costa Sobral ,B Leverington ,T Boettcher ,D Lucchesi ,M Schellenberg ,I Nasteva ,S Belin ,B Sciascia ,A Gioventù ,P Griffith ,T Hadavizadeh ,A Buonaura ,J Qin ,L Dieste Maronas ,S Maccolini ,S A Bouchiba ,G Corti ,N Serra ,Mark Richard James Williams ,M Rotondo ,Jianqiao Wang ,J Dalseno ,E Gabriel ,S Eidelman ,G Lanfranchi ,D Websdale ,A Casais Vidal ,M Andreotti ,Lei Li ,G Meier ,P Robbe ,T Harrison ,Thi Thuy Hang Pham ,D Martínez Santos ,A Smetkina ,Y Yang ,N Neri ,Z Zhu ,K Hennessy ,A Dovbnya ,S Perazzini ,J Marks ,C Abellán Beteta ,L Bian ,A Bizzeti ,R A Mohammed ,A Zhelezov ,A Hicheur ,C Weisser ,S Malde ,O Stenyakin ,P Perret ,G Wormser ,R D Moise ,A Konoplyannikov ,M Chefdeville ,P Krokovny ,Liupan An ,M Kenzie ,S Ricciardi ,V Egorychev ,G Tuci ,V Vorobyev ,Feng Jiang ,Dorothea Vom Bruch ,A Loi ,A Bitadze ,S Bifani ,D Müller ,M Clemencic ,T Gaintseva ,M Firlej ,M Charles ,T Latham ,R Santacesaria ,H M Wark ,A Ene ,I Shchemerov ,Tamaki Holly Mcgrath ,M Szymański ,X Huang ,F Ferreira Rodrigues ,Olga Madejczyk ,B Delaney ,S Nieswand ,P N Swallow ,F Keizer ,D Berninghoff ,S Koliiev ,D J White ,E L Gkougkousis ,S Gambetta ,J Plews ,L De Paula ,R J Hunter ,Mara Senghi Soares ,E Santovetti ,I Belyaev ,D Saranin ,L Douglas ,S Stahl ,Z Xu ,C Prouvé ,H Pullen ,P Mackowiak ,Cesar Luiz Da Silva ,Jifeng Hu ,U Egede ,G Carboni ,Y Xie ,D P O’hanlon ,P Kravchenko ,E Aslanides ,Hangyi Wu ,B Couturier ,Rui Wang ,X Zhu ,R Matev ,Marko Milovanovic ,J Walsh ,M Merk ,A Bertolin ,R Mountain ,M Mazurek ,T Szumlak ,F Reiss ,R J Barlow ,N Tuning ,Zishuo Yang ,G Pietrzyk ,M Reboud ,T Nakada ,А Артамонов ,W Funk ,M Santimaria ,D Xiao ,M T Tran ,D S Mitzel ,G Martellotti ,D C Craik ,D Johnson ,W Barter ,P Durante ,J A De Vries ,A Mödden ,W Hulsbergen ,M Xu ,A Vorobyev ,P E L Clarke ,V Chobanova ,U Marconi ,E Gersabeck ,P Garcia Moreno ,J Maratas ,V Pugatch ,K Wyllie ,Y Shang ,O Lantwin ,F C R Bishop ,L Martinazzoli ,C Haen ,D Dutta ,G Morello ,B D C Westhenry ,A Dziurda ,L L Gerken ,N K Watson ,Ekaterina Trifonova ,J Crkovská ,G Haefeli ,B Souza De Paula ,R Calabrese ,T H Hancock ,A Brea Rodríguez ,Yury Guz ,J Brodzicka ,M Fiorini ,A Bursche ,E Polycarpo ,Zhihong Shen ,J Eschle ,Q Fuehring ,A M Hennequin ,K Gizdov ,M Pili ,Kamil Leszek Fischer ,X R Lyu ,V Gibson ,F Fleuret ,A Merli ,G Punzi ,S Cali ,D S Fitzgerald ,W Krupa ,G Mancinelli ,Q Han ,M Saur ,K Dreimanis ,B Jost ,M Schubiger ,M.-N Minard ,T Lesiak ,J Moroń ,P Ibis ,L Sun ,V Lukashenko ,J M Fernandez-Tenllado Arribas ,Y Gan ,Matteo Salomoni ,A Ukleja ,M Jeżabek ,D Ilin ,S Hansmann-Menzemer ,M Whitehead ,N Cooke ,C D’ambrosio ,E Graverini ,M Calvo Gomez ,B Pietrzyk ,J Albrecht ,P Kopciewicz ,A Beiter ,E Rodrigues ,Y Fan ,L Witola ,M Alexander ,M De Serio ,P Alvarez Cartelle ,W Baldini ,M Poli Lener ,K Klimaszewski ,M Vesterinen ,Jingyi Xu ,M S Rudolph ,D Sanchez Gonzalo ,P Di Nezza ,S De Capua ,F A Garcia Rosales ,L Ferreira Lopes ,A Valassi ,Zhenzi Wang ,A Petrolini ,A Satta ,G Bencivenni ,M H Schune ,D Décamp ,D M Shangase ,D Zuliani ,A Mcnab ,S Gromov ,Y Gao ,A S Boldyrev ,M Bachmayer ,V Franco Lima ,D Wiedner ,M Hecker ,B Schmidt ,V Shevchenko ,Ilaria Neri ,Y Yao ,C H Murphy ,H Malygina ,M Frank ,S Poslavskii ,C B Van Hulse ,L G Scantlebury Smead ,V Obraztsov ,M Gersabeck ,T H Lin ,M Zavertyaev ,Shanzhen Chen ,S Ek-In ,C A Aidala ,Angel Fernando Campoverde Quezada ,D Golubkov ,M J Morello ,Jan Patrick Hammerich ,J G Smeaton ,B Passalacqua ,J A Rodriguez Lopez ,G Raven ,W Kucewicz ,O Schneider ,D Lacarrère ,D J Unverzagt ,S Klaver ,W Wiślicki ,A Pastore ,A Snoch ,L Garrido ,H Yin ,N Valls Canudas ,C Göbel ,M Borsato ,V Matiunin ,G Coombs ,A Leflat ,A Dzyuba ,M Tobin ,M W Dudek ,A Golutvin ,V Lisovskyi ,P Gironella Gironell ,M G Chapman ,Liming Zhang ,D Pereima ,S Ponce ,A Camboni ,N Jurik ,C T Dean ,K R Mattioli ,M Cruz Torres ,M Straticiuc ,U Uwer ,M S Rangel ,F Machefert ,T Gys ,M John ,L M Greeven ,M Giovannetti ,N Voropaev ,M Atzeni ,G H Lovell ,E Gushchin ,A Minotti ,A Lupato ,М Королев ,F Muheim ,E B Shields ,M D Sokoloff ,D Melnychuk ,Guanghua Gong ,D Bobulska ,F Martínez Vidal ,Xiaokang Zhou ,L Soares Lavra ,S Capelli ,L Shekhtman ,V Kudryavtsev ,Rafał Dominik Krawczyk ,Jike Wang ,D Fazzini ,А Малинин ,M Witek ,G Sarpis ,G Cavallero ,C Nunez ,S Popov ,Y Lu ,Peter Švihra ,C Fitzpatrick ,Q Zou ,Chishuai Wang ,P A Gorbounov ,K Carvalho Akiba ,Ming Zeng ,P M Hamilton ,Luis Alberto Granado Cardoso ,Eva Vilella Figueras ,Zhuoming Li ,R Litvinov ,A Papanestis ,N S Nolte ,L Capriotti ,L Grillo ,L Shchutska ,F Baryshnikov ,C Satriano ,M Van Dijk ,K De Bruyn ,E Epple ,J S Butter ,M Bartolini ,I Longstaff ,L Congedo ,F Desse ,S Kretzschmar ,L Dufour ,Jialu Wang ,J H Rademacker ,R Ribatti ,M Pló Casasús ,L Mcconnell ,Z Ren ,L Meyer Garcia ,A Battig ,M Guarise ,F Teubert ,A Carbone ,T D Nguyen ,J Sun ,A Gomes ,S Barsuk ,L L Pappalardo ,F Alessio ,A Ryzhikov ,J J Velthuis ,C A Chavez Barajas ,I Bediaga ,S Jakobsen ,P Naik ,Mengzhen Wang ,M Veronesi ,M Borisyak ,M Hilton ,X Yuan ,A Seuthe ,O Lupton ,A Kondybayeva ,Lishuang Ma ,A Mathad ,D Brundu ,Zhiyu Xiang ,A Danilina ,J Fu ,P Ciambrone ,M Ferro‐Luzzi ,J Heuel ,E Van Herwijnen ,M W Majewski ,M Smith ,Y Sun ,F Bedeschi ,J A Boelhauve ,M Zdybał ,O Maev ,S Blusk ,V Vagnoni ,S Aiola ,Patrícia Camargo Magalhães ,N Polukhina ,A Maevskiy ,Z Yang ,M Karacson ,R Nandakumar ,S E Mitchell ,G J Kunde ,G Zunica

doi:10.1038/s41567-021-01478-8

Abstract

The standard model of particle physics currently provides our best description of fundamental particles and their interactions. The theory predicts that the different charged leptons, the electron, muon and tau, have identical electroweak interaction strengths. Previous measurements have shown that a wide range of particle decays are consistent with this principle of lepton universality. This article presents evidence for the breaking of lepton universality in beauty-quark decays, with a significance of 3.1 standard deviations, based on proton–proton collision data collected with the LHCb detector at CERN’s Large Hadron Collider. The measurements are of processes in which a beauty meson transforms into a strange meson with the emission of either an electron and a positron, or a muon and an antimuon. If confirmed by future measurements, this violation of lepton universality would imply physics beyond the standard model, such as a new fundamental interaction between quarks and leptons.

Full Text