Ten-year follow-up results of patients with persistent atrial fibrillation treated by combined pulmonary vein isolation and complex fractionated atrial electrocardiogram ablation

Abstract

Abstract Background For persistent atrial fibrillation (AF), pulmonary vein isolation (PVI) alone is associated with lower success rate compared to paroxysmal AF and additional strategies are needed. Ablation targeting on complex fractionated atrial electrograms (CFAE) is an alternative method. Although clinical benefits of the strategy combined PVI and CFAE ablation have not been shown by large trials, clinical situations and consequences of this approach have not been clearly demonstrated during very long term follow-up. Purpose This study aimed to retrospectively investigate clinical outcomes of patients with persistent AF treated by the approach combined PVI and CFAE ablation during a follow-up period of 10 years. Methods 73 patients (59.4±8.1 years, 64 male, AF history 5.5 years) with persistent (23, 31.5%) and long-standing persistent AF (50, 68.5%) who underwent combined PVI and CFAE ablation in the first procedure were included. Structural heart disease was found in 9 patients, and a history of ablation for typical atrial flutter (AFL) in 4. A complete CFAE mapping in the left atrium and coronary sinus was performed with a 3-D mapping system (EnSite NavX). All CFAEs defined as electrograms with continuous activities or mean cycle length detected by the system <80 ms were eliminated. All patients were controlled regularly during the first year with 12-lead ECG and Holter monitoring and followed by annual control. The electronic health records for all patients were extensively investigated and the patients were interviewed in 2020-2022. Any documented atrial tachyarrhythmia (ATA) after 3-month blanking period was regarded as recurrence. Results Mean 2.2±1.2 (1-5) ablation procedures were performed in each patient. After index ablation, 18 (24.7%) were free of ATAs during 10-year follow-up. 26 (35.6%) had recurrence of only AF, 6 (8.2%) of only AFL and 23 (31.5%) had both AF and AFL. The proportion of AFL was 39.7% with 6 typical AFL. After multiple ablation procedures, 33 (45.2%) patients were free of ATA during the follow-up. 23 (31.5%) had recurrence of only AF, 5 (6.8%) of only AFL and 12 (16.4%) of both AF and AFL. The proportion of AFL was 23.2% with no typical AFL. At 1-year follow-up, freedom of ATAs in persistent AF was higher than that in long-standing AF (65.2 vs. 40.0%, p=0.033) and no significant difference was found after 2 years (47.8 vs. 34.0%, p=0.129) until 10 years (30.4 vs. 22.0%, p=0.167, Figure 1). No difference was observed between these subgroups after multiple procedures at 10-year follow-up (47.8 vs. 44.0%, p=0.708, Figure 2). Conclusions PVI plus CAFE ablation in patients with persistent AF led to a high recurrence of ATA after index ablation. Difference of ATA-freedom between persistent and long-standing persistent AF groups was found only 1 year after the index procedure, but not during further follow-up. Incidence of post-ablation AFL was particularly high, even after multiple ablation procedures.Figure 1Figure 2