Temporal Variation in Activity of Bats and the Design of Echolocation-Monitoring Studies

Abstract

I used Anabat II bat detectors to monitor echolocation calls of bats over two streams in the Oregon Coast Range for a total of 195 detector-nights. Activity of bats was positively correlated with biomass of insects and minimum nightly temperature, and was negatively correlated with length of night; activity levels at the two streams were positively correlated. Activity of bats was not significantly correlated with either hours of moonlight or with phase of moon. Level of activity within a night generally peaked shortly after sunset with a second, smaller peak in activity shortly before sunrise, but patterns varied substantially among nights. Total nightly activity at a site also varied substantially among nights, sometimes varying several-fold on consecutive nights. To assess the implications of temporal variation in activity of bats on sampling, I randomly sampled subsets of the data using from 2- to 12-night sample periods and calculated mean levels of activity for each subset. For subsets with seven or more nights, >60% of the subsets had means that were within 20% of the mean of the entire dataset. Less than 50% of the subsets had means within 10% of the mean of the entire dataset for any number of nights subsampled. When comparing activity between sites, use of blocked or paired designs improved sampling efficiency by 20%. Failure to account for temporal variation in activity of bats when designing research projects and monitoring programs could result in biased estimates of activity of bats.