Teaching the content and context of science: the effect of using historical narratives to teach the nature of science and science content in an undergraduate introductory geology course

Abstract

This study reports the use of historically accurate narratives (short stories) to simultaneously teach geology content and the nature of science in an introductory, undergraduate geology course. The stories describe key events involved in the development of geologists’ ideas about continental drift/plate tectonics and deep time/the age of the Earth. The design of the stories provides a highly contextualized setting which is designed to promote NOS and geology understanding by explicitly attending students to fundamental concepts and requiring students to reflect on the short story content. Evidence is reported to support the conclusion that students using these short stories constructed a better understanding of 1) the variety of processes involved in the construction of scientific knowledge, 2) the subjective nature of data that allows it to be interpreted differently by different scientists, and 3) the roles that culture and society play in determining the way in which scientific work is conducted and scientific ideas are constructed, while maintaining equal levels of understanding of geology content when compared to students who did not use the short stories. In some cases, students’ preconceptions about objectivity in science, the degree to which scientific ideas can be considered as “proven” or “true,” and the role of discovery in science appear to have adversely affected their ability to interpret the short story content in the ways intended. In addition, students’ misconceptions about differences in how oceanic and continental plates were formed and geologists’ use of relative and absolute dating techniques, especially the appropriate uses of radio-isotopic dating, are described. This study has implications for science instructors as they make efforts to efficiently use class time and curriculum resources to teach about the both the content and context of