Teaching empathy: comparison of a virtual reality experience using head-mounted display versus group streaming

Abstract

ABSTRACT Empathy, an integral component of bedside manners, correlates with good healthcare provision. Training physician assistant (PA) students using Head-Mounted Display (HMD) virtual reality (VR) contributed to significant empathy increases. This pilot study, which relied on a retrospective analysis, compared a VR experience using HMD to a streamed modality (due to COVID safety) with PA students to measure empathy. We hypothesized that fully immersive and interactive HMD VR would lead to a statistically significant increase in empathy versus the streaming modality. The “Alfred Lab” VR allows viewers to “embody” a 74-year-old African American man with vision and hearing loss. The University of New England PA class of 2021 (n = 47) completed the HMD lab while the class of 2022 (n = 50) viewed the streaming modality as a group. Identical pre/post surveys were completed by each cohort. The analysis utilized paired sample t-tests, ANOVA, frequency analysis (quantitative), and content analysis with thematic coding (qualitative). The results for each cohort revealed a statistically significant increase in empathy (p < 0.05) after completing the VR lab (pre- to post-test results). The comparison of both cohorts (HMD versus group streaming) revealed no noteworthy difference. Streaming VR could improve access to PA programs unable to acquire expensive VR equipment yet still allow for the development of empathy.