Tantalum-doped hydroxyapatite thin films: Synthesis and characterization

Abstract

To achieve a good bioactivity, magnetron-sputtered (MS) hydroxyapatite (HA) coatings have to be stoichiometric and crystalline. It has also been suggested that doping HA with metallic elements improves its bioactivity but frequently reduces its Young’s modulus. Therefore, efforts are still necessary to identify adequate growth conditions, good doping elements and finally to grow doped HA films. In a first attempt, HA films have been synthesized by MS. Our conditions enabled us to grow at ∼10nmmin−1 stoichiometric and crystallized HA coatings that presented a strong texture. The latter is discussed in view of the competitive growth of the material under the strong electron and ion bombardments used here. Based on ab initio calculations identifying Ta as a promising doping element, we then investigated the growth of Ta-doped hydroxyapatite (HA:Ta) by magnetron co-sputtering. The HA:Ta films were in situ crystallized. Our data reveals that for Ta contents <4.5at.%, Ta could substitute Ca in the HA cell. For higher doping contents, a deviation from the stoichiometric compound is observed and CaO appears. By nanoindentation, we have measured an elastic modulus of 120±9GPa for a Ta content of 3at.%. This value is very close to the value of 110GPa calculated by ab initio calculations, supporting the substitution scenario. The elasticity drop may be understood by screening of the ionic interaction between constituents in HA upon Ta incorporation.