Taking Our Pulse: Examining 5 Years of Data from the Association of Pediatric Program Directors Research and Scholarship Learning Community

Abstract

BackgroundThe Association of Pediatric Program Directors Research and Scholarship Learning Community (RSLC) prioritizes and comprehensively reviews medical education surveys directed to residency program leadership. Each survey is reviewed by two members of RSLC and the Chair and Vice Chair using a standardized scoring rubric and a limited number of surveys are accepted per cycle. MethodsInternal review data from 2015 to 2020 were analyzed to determine factors associated with survey acceptance, and for surveys accepted for distribution, determine factors associated with response rates or dissemination status. One-Way analysis of variance (ANOVA) assessed differences in evaluation scores by initial determination status. T-tests and Pearson Product Correlation assessed associations between evaluation scores and response rates by dissemination status. ResultsThe majority (47/81; 58%) of surveys submitted to RSLC are eventually accepted for distribution. Response rates for distributed surveys varied between 14% and 73%. Most (35/47; 74%) surveys distributed through RSLC are presented (62%) and/or published (60%). Higher review scores were associated with acceptance for distribution but not with response rates or dissemination status. ConclusionMost surveys are eventually accepted by RSLC for distribution and those distributed often get published or presented despite variability in response rates.