T1a renal cell carcinoma on unenhanced CT: analysis of detectability and imaging features.

Abstract

BackgroundIncreasing use of unenhanced computed tomography (CT) has been associated with the increasing incidental detection of renal cell carcinoma (RCC) at an earlier stage.PurposeTo evaluate the characteristics in detecting and differentiating T1a RCCs on unenhanced CT.Material and MethodsWe retrospectively reviewed 68 patients with 68 T1a RCCs and 39 benign regions. Two radiologists interpreted the images on unenhanced axial CT and performed a blinded and independent review of T1a RCCs. The readers evaluated the presence of RCC and differentiated the detected lesions.ResultsThe consensus of two readers detected 53 (78%) RCCs. Of the 53 detected RCCs, 42 (62%) RCCs were correctly diagnosed and 11 (16%) masses were misdiagnosed as benign. Of the 39 benign regions, 29 (74%) cysts were diagnosed correctly, but 10 (26%) cysts were misdiagnosed as malignant. The following values of the radiologists were obtained by consensus: sensitivity = 61.8% (42/68); specificity = 74.4% (29/39); positive predictive value = 80.8% (42/52); negative predictive value = 55.0% (29/55); accuracy = 66.4% (71/107). The receiver operating characteristic curve of consensus was 0.754. Inter-observer correlation was κ = 0.849. There was a significant difference in tumor size (P = 0.019) and the contour type of tumor (P = 0.0207) between correctly diagnosed RCCs and not correctly diagnosed RCCs.ConclusionOur findings showed that tumor size and contour type could affect the detection and differentiation of T1a RCC on unenhanced CT. To detect and differentiate T1a RCC on unenhanced CT is difficult. However, the findings from this study may help detection of RCCs on unenhanced CT.