Synonymous nucleotide substitution rates of beta-tubulin and histone genes conform to high overall genomic rates in rodents but not in sea urchins.

Abstract

Sea urchin and rodent genomes have been posited to evolve rapidly as indicated by divergences in single copy nuclear DNA sequences. We have examined whether the synonymous substitution rates of three highly conserved genes, beta-tubulin, histone H4, and histone H3, adhere to these high genomic substitution rates by comparing sequences between two sea urchins, Strongylocentrotus purpuratus and Lytechinus pictus, and between rodents and humans. Whereas the rate of change between the 3' untranslated regions of the beta-tubulin cDNA of S. purpuratus (Sp-beta 1), sequenced in this study, and of L. pictus (Lp-beta 3) was consistent with the overall rate of change estimated from previous DNA hybridization results between these species, the synonymous substitution rates for the carboxyl domains of these beta-tubulins, as well as for the late histones H4 and H3, were significantly depressed. In contrast, synonymous nucleotide substitution rates between rodents and between rodent and human for the carboxyl domain proper of identical beta-tubulin isotypes and for histone H4 and H3.1 did not differ from the overall rate of change for the rodent genomes. Moreover, an analysis of paralogous human and mouse beta-tubulin sequences supported the conclusion that the synonymous substitution rates in the mouse were higher than those in the human. Differences in constraint on evolutionary change were not evident strictly from the conserved amino acid sequences and base compositions of these genes. Other constraining influences seemed more relevant to the departure of the synonymous substitution rates of the sea urchin beta-tubulin and histone coding regions from the average genomic rate.