Surgical treatment in child’s congenital toe syndactyly: Risk factor of recurrence, complication and poor clinical outcomes

Abstract

IntroductionSurgical treatment of toe syndactyly remains controversial. The strong demand from parents for a cosmetic release is increasing in our societies. But is it worth it? The objective was to assess medium-long term outcomes and to identify the risk factors of recurrence, complication and poor clinical outcomes. MethodsSixty-eight toe syndactylies (38 patients) undergoing surgery between 2008 and 2017 with a follow-up higher than two years were included consecutively and retrospectively. Four children (four syndactylies) were lost to follow-up and excluded. The mean age of the first surgery was 3.9 years old (0.8–16.7) and cohort mean follow-up was 6.9 years (2.8–11.2). In all patients, web release with a commissural dorsal flap was performed and associated a cutaneous resurfacing (spontaneous epithelialization, full-thickness skin graft taken from the popliteal crease, or a hyaluronic acid ester matrix). ResultsEighteen syndactylies (28.1%) in 14 patients recurred and one syndactyly required revision surgery. An age of surgery above two years was the only risk factor for recurrence found in univariate (OD = 0.27[0.08;0.85];p = 0.02) and multivariate studies (IC 95% = 0.05−0.68;p = 0.02). Seven complications (11.7%) in seven syndactylies (6 patients) were reported with six keloids (9.4%) and one scar retraction (1.6%). Each complication underwent an additional procedure. African ethnicity (N = 15) represents a risk factor (N = 4/15; OD = 0.12[0.009;0.97];p = 0.02) for keloids formation. Withey's average score is 4.9 (1–11), mean OxAFQ-C score was 52/60 (30–60), 67% would repeat the surgery and 69% felt satisfied at last follow-up. The simple syndactyly would appear less satisfied than complex or complicated (p = 0.02). ConclusionsSurgical treatment of child’s congenital syndactyly involves a risk of recurrence (28%) and potential complications (11,7%). Performed surgical procedure over two years old increase the risk of recurrence. African ethnicity is a risk factor in scarring complication. Only half of simple syndactylies are satisfied and prone to repeat the surgery.