Surgical Errors Happen, but Are Learners Trained to Recover from Them? A Survey of North American Surgical Residents and Fellows

Abstract

Surgical training necessitates graded supervision and supported independence in order to reach competence. In developing surgical skills, trainees can, and will, make mistakes. A key skill required for independent practice is the ability to recover from an error or unexpected complication. Error recovery includes recognizing and managing a technical error in order to ensure patient safety and may be underrepresented in current educational approaches. The purpose of this study is to explore residents' experiences and perceptions of error recovery training in surgical procedures. An online survey was sent to surgical program directors in the United States and Canada using the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education and the Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada distribution lists. Participating programs distributed the survey to their residents and fellows. The survey was composed of Likert-scale items, yes/no questions as well as open-ended questions focused on perceptions, experiences, and factors that influence to error recovery training in the operating room. A total of 206 surveys were completed. Overall, 99% (n = 203) agreed or strongly agreed that error recovery is an important competency for future practice. This was reflected in free-text response: "Errors can be minimized but they are inevitable, so certainly believe a surgical curriculum that addresses error recovery is of paramount importance." While 83% (n = 170) feel confident recovering from minor errors, only 34% (n = 68) feel confident that they could recover from major errors that are likely to have serious consequences on patient safety. Overall, residents do not consider that they have adequate training in error recovery, with only 37% (n = 72) felt they were adequately trained to recover from major errors. It was also mentioned "The quality of learning regarding error recovery depends entirely on the attending." Opportunities to learn to recover from technical errors in the operating room are valued by surgical trainees, but they perceive their training to be both inadequate and variable. This contributes to a lack of confidence in error recovery skills throughout their surgical training. There is a need to explore how best to integrate error recovery into more formal surgical curricula in order to better support learners and, ultimately, contribute to increased surgical safety.