SURG-01. Management of solitary brain metastasis less than 4 cm in diameter. Surgical resection versus stereotactic radiotherapy: a meta-analysis

Abstract

IntroductionTo treat a solitary metastasis in the brain, surgical resection and/or radiotherapy are the standard treatments of care. However, the clinical scenarios in which to use these techniques alone or in combination are controversial. While a course of stereotactic radiotherapy is often administered to a patient who presents with multiple metastases, surgical resection is often directed against a larger solitary brain metastasis before irradiating the resection bed. The management of a smaller solitary tumor (diameter less than 4 cm) is less clear. Accordingly, our meta-analysis assembled studies that focused on patients with a solitary tumor less than 4 cm in diameter.MethodsFollowing PRISMA guidelines (PROSPERO ID: CRD42021242434), we searched PubMed, Web of Knowledge, and Cochrane Library databases for randomized controlled trials (RCT) and observational studies comparing surgery to radiotherapy for solitary metastatic brain tumors less than 4 cm in diameter. From 498 total records, we included 9 studies for meta-analysis. Analysis was performed on R.Results2 RCTs and 7 observational studies were identified. 431 patients underwent surgical intervention, and 349 patients exclusively underwent radiotherapy. The surgical treatment cohort did not exhibit a difference in 1-year (OR [95% CI] = 0.866 [0.609–1.289]), 2-year (1.7 [0.843–3.428]), or overall survival (1.18 [0.598–2.327]). However, the surgical treatment group demonstrated greater local tumor recurrence after 1-year (3.975 [1.979–7.987]) and overall local recurrence (3.045 [1.276 - 7.268]). There was no difference between the overall rates of distant recurrence (0.565 [0.218 - 1.466]).ConclusionsOur analysis opens more discussion about the management of solitary brain metastasis. Patient selection is paramount in achieving better local control. Stereotactic radiotherapy should be considered for treatment of solitary brain metastasis less than 4 cm in diameter in selected patients. Future randomized control trials for small solitary masses are recommended.