Superiority of 24-hour outpatient monitoring over multi-stage exercise testing for the evaluation of syncope

Abstract

Twenty-four hour outpatient monitoring was compared with maximum multi-stage Treadmill exercise testing for the detection of dysrhythmias producing syncope or near syncope in 119 patients. All patients had cardiovascular disorders; only 21% had coronary artery disease. Patients with obvious cause of syncope and/or significant dysrhythmias by resting electrocardiograms (ECGs) were excluded. A significant dysrhythmia was found which was considered the probable cause of syncope or pre-syncope in 76 patients (64%). A non-cardiac cause was found in tachycardia, exercise testing identified only patients with complex ventricular dysrhythmias and missed 64% of these. Overall, dysrhythmias were found by ambulatory monitoring alone in 63 patients, by exercise testing alone in only three, and by both in 10. It is concluded that: 1) in the majority of patients with syncope or pre-syncope suspected to be of a cardiac origin, a dysrhythmia can be found; 2) ambulatory monitoring is far superior to exercise testing for detection of dysrhythmias; 3) exercise testing increases the yield for complex ventricular dysrhythmias.