Superior performance of a trailing edge low-latitude population of an intertidal marine invertebrate

Abstract

The objective of this study is to compare ecologically relevant measures of performance over a broad range of latitude of a species subjected to climate change. Do populations change in relative function over a wide range of latitude? Are populations at the low latitude trailing edge in danger of extinction in the onset of thermal stress? Coastal marine species with planktonic larvae can range over an enormous span of latitude and thermal environments. The fiddler crab Leptuca pugilator extends from high-latitude (41.75°N) winter-frozen Massachusetts tidal flats in the north to subtropical low latitude flats in Florida (24.55°N), where they may be active at the surface over most of the year. We characterized the air environment for males at three sites (New York – latitude 40.0°N, Beaufort, North Carolina – latitude 34.7°N, Panacea Florida, latitude 30.0°N) over the geographic-thermal range, and found major differences in temperature, wind speed, humidity, and vapor pressure deficit. Florida L. pugilator males preferred warmer sand than North Carolina and New York crabs. Local adaptation to latitude-dependent thermal conditions might suggest tradeoffs in performance as a function of temperature. We examined measures of predator escape performance (running speed and righting speed) and overall condition reflecting endurance rivalry success (endurance on a treadmill and major claw closing force) over a wide range of test temperatures. Predator escape rates increase steadily with increasing temperature, but endurance rivalry measures show an intermediate temperature peak of performance. We tested the hypothesis of tradeoffs, with expected local superiority of performance according to regional thermal differences. But instead, the trailing edge Florida males were superior to the higher latitude populations, over a broad range of temperature, but especially at higher temperatures, for all four types of performance measures. The trailing edge population of L. pugilator, in thermal terms, is therefore likely not vulnerable to near future further effects of warming in terms of performance measures related to male reproductive and feeding activities and escape from predators. Fiddler crabs appear to display niche conservatism for stronger performance at tropical temperatures. Such a natural tropical superiority in performance might have to be accommodated in future conceptions of response of marine species to climate change with broad latitudinal distributions in the tropics.