Superior Capsule Reconstruction Using Fascia Lata Allograft Compared With Double- and Single-Layer Dermal Allograft: A Biomechanical Study

Abstract

To biomechanically characterize superior capsule reconstruction (SCR) using fascia lata allograft, double-layer dermal allograft, and single-layer dermal allograft for a clinically relevant massive irreparable rotator cuff tear involving the entire supraspinatus and 50% of the infraspinatus tendons. Eight cadaveric specimens were tested in 0°, 30°, and 60° abduction for (1) intact, (2) massive rotator cuff tear, (3) SCR using fascia lata, (4) SCR using double-layer dermis, and (5) SCR using single-layer dermis. Superior translation and subacromial contact pressure were measured. Statistical analysis was conducted using repeated measures ANOVA or paired t test with P < .05. Massive rotator cuff tear significantly increased superior translation of the humeral head at all abduction angles (P < .05). At 0° abduction, all SCR conditions significantly decreased superior translation compared with the massive tear but did not restore translation (P < .05) to intact. Fascia lata and double-layer dermis SCR restored superior translation to intact at 30° and 60° of abduction, but single-layer dermis did not. Subacromial contact pressure at 0° of abduction significantly decreased with SCR with fascia lata and double-layer dermis compared with tear. At 30°, all SCR conditions significantly decreased subacromial contact pressure. Single-layer dermis graft thickness significantly decreased more than fascia lata during testing (P= .02). For SCR tensioned at 20° glenohumeral abduction, all 3 graft types may restore superior translation and subacromial contact pressure depending on the glenohumeral abduction angle; fascia lata and double-layer dermis may be more effective than single-layer dermis. If a dermal graft is to be used for SCR, consideration should be given to doubling the graft for increased thickness and better restorative biomechanical properties, which may improve clinical outcomes following SCR.