Subsurface Drainage and Subirrigation Effects on Water Quality in Southeast North Dakota

Abstract

Rising water tables, increased soil salinity, and poor trafficability have prompted rapid expansion of subsurface drainage in the Red River Valley of the North in eastern North Dakota and northwestern Minnesota. A conventional subsurface drainage (CD) and subirrigation (SI) field study was conducted in southeast North Dakota from 2008 to 2010 to investigate drainage and subirrigation effects on water quality. Water samples were collected biweekly from a sump pump structure (used as the water inlet and outlet) and 16 observation wells within the field. Water quality variables included chloride (Cl-), electrical conductivity (EC), total dissolved solids (TDS), sodium adsorption ratio (SAR), sodium (Na+), orthophosphate (PO4-P), ammonium (NH4-N), nitrite and nitrate (NOx-N), Kjeldahl nitrogen (TKN), and total nitrogen (TN). A three-factor partially nested design and a general linear model with random effects were employed to compare the effects of water management treatment, distance to drain, and well locations (soil heterogeneity) on water quality. The most significant water quality difference was found at the outlet structure, where a significant difference (p < 0.001) between the CD and SI water was found for all ten variables. The water quality of the drainage water was better than the subirrigation water from the aquifer, except for the NOx-N, EC, and TDS concentrations. Well water Cl- concentrations inside the field were significantly greater in SI compared with CD water; EC, TDS, SAR, and Na+ were not. In contrast, EC, TDS, SAR, and Na+ were significantly higher at two well locations, indicating that soil heterogeneity affected the water quality. Due to SI practice, a significant difference for Cl-, SAR, and Na+ was found between the locations closest to and farthest from the drains during the SI practice, which implies that the SI process may cause soil properties to change in the future. Overall, well locations significantly affected PO4-P, NOx-N, and TN, indicating that the soil physical and chemical properties affected the water quality, and these effects could overcome the difference due to different water treatments.