Study on sustainable defluoridization approaches for rural drinking water treatment in northern China

Abstract

Groundwater for potable uses containing high fluoride is a worldwide threat to human health. Electrocoagulation is a sustainable approach for decentralized treatment. This study aims to analyse the economic and environmental impacts of electrocoagulation applied at different scale in rural area of northern China by life cycle cost (LCC) and life cycle assessment (LCA) methods. Decentralized treatment for defluoridization in rural Fangshan District, Beijing, where the groundwater quality is typical in northern China, is surveyed as a case study. Three scenarios were evaluated. In scenario 1 (S1) all domestic water is electrocoagulated at community scale without dual water supply system. In scenario 2 (S2) only water for potable uses is electrocoagulated at community scale and raw water and treated water are distributed via dual water pipeline systems. In scenario 3 (S3) water for potable uses is electrocoagulated at household scale. Life cycle assessment is performed with openLCA software and Ecoinvent database. S1 has the highest impacts for eutrophication and global warming. S2 has the lowest impact for toxicity but highest impact for ozone layer depletion. S3 has the lowest impact for global warming and acidification but highest impact for human toxicity. S2 is the costliest while S3 is the most economical. In this case, life cycle cost and global warming impact are the most restricted factors so electrocoagulation at household scale is recommended.