Study of Pd–Ag dental alloys: examination of effect of casting porosity on fatigue behavior and microstructural analysis

Abstract

The goals of this study were to investigate the fatigue limits of two Pd-Ag alloys (Ivoclar Vivadent) with differing mechanical properties and varying proportions of secondary alloying elements, examine the effect of casting porosity on fatigue behavior, and determine the effect of casting size on microstructures and Vickers hardness. The alloys selected were: IPS d.SIGN 59 (59.2Pd-27.9Ag-8.2Sn-2.7In-1.3Zn); and IS 64 (59.9Pd-26.0Ag-7.0Sn-2.8Au-1.8 Ga-1.5In-1.0Pt). Tension test bars, heat-treated to simulate dental porcelain application, were subjected to cyclic loading at 10 Hz, with R-ratio of -1 for amplitudes of compressive and tensile stress. Two replicate specimens were tested at each stress amplitude. Fracture surfaces were examined with a scanning electron microscope (SEM). Sectioned fatigue specimens and additional cast specimens simulating copings for a maxillary central incisor restoration were also examined with the SEM, and Vickers hardness was measured using 1 kg load. Casting porosity was evaluated in sectioned fatigue fracture specimens, using an image analysis program. The fatigue limit (2 × 10(6) loading cycles) of IS 64 was approximately 0.20 of its 0.2% yield strength, while the fatigue limit of d.SIGN 59 was approximately 0.25 of its 0.2% yield strength. These relatively low ratios of fatigue limit to 0.2% yield strength are similar to those found previously for high-palladium dental alloys, and are attributed to their complex microstructures and casting porosity. Complex fatigue fracture surfaces with striations were observed for both alloys. Substantial further decrease in the number of cycles for fatigue failure only occurred when the pore size and volume percentage became excessive. While the heat-treated alloys had equiaxed grains with precipitates, the microstructural homogenization resulting from simulated porcelain firing differed considerably for the coping and fatigue test specimens; the latter specimens had significantly higher values of Vickers hardness.