Study of an exergy method for environmental evaluation assessment in the early design phase using comparative LCA and exergy approach

Abstract

Environmental evaluation analysis made at an early design stage is an important practical problem because existing approaches such as the LCA method require detailed information about the studied product or service. Consequently, to be efficient such a method requires a product or service located in an advanced development phase. An exergy method offers an appropriate solution for an environmental evaluation analysis at an early design stage. The theoretical model has been validated in previous journal articles. The goal of the present article is to validate the concordance of the results provided by the exergy and LCA approach, as LCA is a widely used approach even though the scientific reliability of LCA techniques has been questioned. This paper addresses the last phase of the validation of the exergy approach by comparing results of a case study analysed through both commercial LCA software and an exergy approach.