Structural Effects on the Solvolytic Reactivity of Carboxylic and Sulfonic Acid Chlorides. Comparisons with Gas-Phase Data for Cation Formation

Abstract

Kinetic data for solvolyses of 28 acid chlorides in 97% w/w trifluoroethanol (TFE)-water spanning over 10 (9) in rate constant at 25 degrees C are obtained directly or by short extrapolation from published values. G3 calculations of the energy required for cation formation in the gas phase are validated from proton affinities and from other experimental data. G3 calculations of heterolytic bond dissociation enthalpies (HBDEs) for formation of cations from acid chlorides in the gas phase show the following trends when compared with the solvolysis rate constants: (i) electron-rich sulfonyl chlorides and most carboxylic acid chlorides, including thione derivatives, give a satisfactory linear correlation with a significant negative slope; (ii) most sulfonyl chlorides and some chloroformates and thio derivatives have higher HBDEs and fit another correlation with a small, negative slope. A significant deviation is observed for the acyl series (RCOCl), for which both solvolysis rates and HBDEs increase in the order R = Bu ( t ) < Pr ( i ) < Et < Me. The deviation may be explained either by a prior hydration mechanism or preferably by electrostatic effects on the formation of small cations. The above results of structural effects support independent evidence from solvent effects that cationic ionization reaction pathways (with nucleophilic solvent assistance or S N2 character) are involved in the solvolyses of acid chlorides.