Strong genetic structuring without assortative mating or reduced hybrid survival in an onychophoran in the Tallaganda State Forest region, Australia

Abstract

Genetic studies have revealed a large degree of previously unappreciated diversity in morphologically conserved taxa. To understand the implications of this phenomenon, studies investigating the processes responsible for generating and maintaining functional and neutral diversity within such taxa are needed. With this aim, patterns of differentiation across a contact zone between two catchment-specific, and genetically and subtly morphologically distinguishable, races of the onychophoran Euperipatoides rowelli Reid, 1996 at the Tallaganda State Forest study system, Australia, were quantified using diagnostic body-pattern differences, microsatellite markers, and the cytochrome c oxidase subunit I (COI) mitochondrial gene. These data were used to test whether hybridization occurred, and whether the reduced survival of hybrids compared with non-hybrids and/or assortative mating were potentially important factors in retaining the divergence between these races, which probably arose during isolation in Pleistocene glacial refuges. It was found that hybrids at the focal contact zone do not have reduced embryo-to-adult survival compared with non-hybrids, and that races apparently freely interbreed without substantial assortative mating, consistent with little or no cost to hybridization. Nonetheless, at their respective transect ends the races remain distinct. This phenomenon was attributed to the elevated location of the contact zone, which is likely to make it poor habitat for E. rowelli, and thus may restrict dispersal and gene flow. There was also tentative evidence for a relaxed selection against hybridization in the hybrid zone, and the relative importance of these two explanations will require separate investigation. © 2014 The Linnean Society of London, Biological Journal of the Linnean Society, 2014, 111, 589–602.