Stress distributions of the short stem and the tapered wedge stem at different alignments: a finite element analysis study

Abstract

The mechanical effects of stem length reduction and stem alignment on the surrounding femur remain unknown. This study directly compared the stress distribution on the surrounding femur of existing tapered wedge stems and short stems and examined the properties of stress distribution at different stem alignments in three dimensions. Finite element analysis was conducted for standing and walking. The cementless stem was appropriately sized to ensure adequate contact with the medial cortical bone line that contours the medullary cavity. The stem neck axis was aligned with the femoral neck axis in the mid-position and placed in 2° of the varus and valgus, 3° of flexion and extension, and 10° and 40° of anteversion. Regardless of stem length, the trend of stress distribution was similar. The short stem generated less stress around the stem than the tapered wedge stem. In the coronal plane, the effect of varus and valgus deflection was small. In the sagittal plane, the stress generated around the stem was higher in the extended position than in the flexed position. In the horizontal plane, the stress generated around the stem was higher when the stem anteversion was smaller. Depending on the design, short stems can reduce the stress on the surrounding bone, compared to a longer tapered wedge with similar stress distribution. Additionally, a short stem can reduce the effect of the varus position. Stems should be placed to achieve stable initial fixation while noting that stresses increase with extension and reduced anteversion.