Streamlining universal screening for lynch syndrome (LS): Towards improved yield of genetic counseling (GC).

Abstract

503 Background: LS is largely underdiagnosed although Universal Screening (US) in colorectal cancer (CRC) patients through MisMatch Repair deficiency (MMR-d) testing is widely endorsed. Low adherence to guidelines among oncologists may be partly due to a lack of consensus on whether all MMR-d patients should be referred to GC/Genetic Testing (GT). As BRAF mutation rules out LS, we estimated the increased yield of LS diagnosis from GC /GT which could be obtained by selecting candidates for GC through BRAF testing. Methods: From 2011 to 2016, 1447 consecutive stage I-IV CRC surgical patients at a single institution, underwent immunohistochemistry (IHC) for LS using anti MLH1, MSH2, MSH6 and PMS2 antibodies. Oncologists were invited to refer all MMR-d patients to GC/GT. BRAFV600E testing was carried out only in case of MLH1 protein loss at IHC. Results: MMR-d was found in 194 patients (13%), with 171 showing loss of MLH1 expression (88%). Oncologists referred 27 (16%) to GC. Among the 21 who underwent GC, BRAF testing and GT, 9 were BRAF wild type (wt) (43%) and none had LS. Among the 23 MMR-d patients with loss of expression of MSH2, MSH6 or PMS2 (≠MLH1), oncologists referred 9 to GC (39%): 7 underwent GC / GT and 3 carried LS (43%) at GT. Median age was 76 years (range 30-97) in the MMR-d group, 78 (range 41-97) in the MLH1 group and 63 (range 30-86) in the ≠MLH1 group. Overall, LS was diagnosed in 3 of the 28 MMR-d patients (11%) who underwent GC /GT, possibly an underestimate due to the advanced median age of our MLH1 loss patients. Had we only offered GC to the 9 BRAF wt patients among the 21 with MLH1 loss, we could have avoided 12 (57%) of the GC sessions conducted, increasing the yield of LS diagnosis from 3/28 (11%) to 3/16 (19%) (75% increase). Conclusions: When US for LS is adopted, a GC referral rate reduction of 57% among MLH1 loss patients, and an overall increase in the yield of GC of about 75% can be obtained by testing for BRAF mutation before oncologist referral to GC rather than after. As multistep selection of patients by oncologists may be unfeasible, CRC pathology reports with combined MMR-d and BRAF testing (for MLH1 loss at IHC) and an ‘LS suspicion alert’ could improve oncologists’ awareness of LS and compliance with guidelines.